Skip to content
HousingGauge

Episode 3 · with Chris & Ryan

Ann Arbor vs. Kalamazoo: Are College Towns Really Safe Investments?

October 30, 2026 · 47:24 · Chris and Ryan

The University of Michigan has grown to a record 53,488 students while Western Michigan University has lost more than a quarter of its enrollment since 2017. Yet Kalamazoo's median sale price is up 12% on the year and Ann Arbor's is down 7%. Chris has owned rentals in both towns, and he walks through the left-brain case for Ann Arbor, nine doors and a lot of drama in Kalamazoo, and why the price of a home matters more than the prestige of the university. Then the hosts go on the record: Kalamazoo beats Ann Arbor, and Chris waits three years to buy Ann Arbor again.

In this episode

  • The enrollment paradoxSince fall 2017, University of Michigan enrollment is up 16% to a record 53,488, and Western Michigan's is down 27% to 16,696. Over the same decade, Kalamazoo's typical home value rose 83% and Ann Arbor's 61%.
  • Read the fine printRedfin's median sale price has Kalamazoo up 12.1% and Ann Arbor down 6.9% on the year, but that depends on which homes sold. Zillow's typical home value has both still rising (Kalamazoo +5.1%, Ann Arbor +2.6% in the city ZIP codes), and Kalamazoo's price per square foot actually fell 9.7%.
  • Price, not prestigeA typical Kalamazoo sale costs 4.3 years of the city's median household income; in Ann Arbor it's 5.6. Kalamazoo's cheapest ZIP code, 49007, has gained 140% in ten years.
  • Tenants and dollars per hourChris's Ann Arbor rental houses PhD students and has never sat empty. His nine doors in Kalamazoo made well over $200,000 (the fourplex alone sold for a $200,000 profit) but cost too much time and drama, so he sold them all.
  • On the recordBoth hosts say Kalamazoo will outperform Ann Arbor. Chris is holding his Ann Arbor house, buying neither for now, and says Ann Arbor will be a great buy in about three years.

First, the scandal

One second at the Big House

Every episode starts with a scandal, and this one is Kalamazoo's. On September 5, in the season opener at Michigan Stadium, Western Michigan led No. 16 Michigan 12–7 with seven seconds left. Bryce Underwood's first Hail Mary sailed out of the back of the end zone and the clock read zero. The Broncos had won.

Then the officials went to replay and put one second back. Underwood threw again, JJ Buchanan caught a 47-yard touchdown, and Michigan won 13–12. The Big Ten said its official game clock showed a second left when a Western Michigan defender touched the ball; NBC said its broadcast cameras "are not the official arbiter of timekeeping." A few days later the Mid-American Conference said replay protocol hadn't been followed and asked the NCAA to recognize Western Michigan as the winner.

Chris, who went to neither school: "Little brother's about to beat up big brother." Read the coverage: CBS Sports, Sports Illustrated, the Big Ten's explanation and the MAC's response.

Aerial view of Michigan Stadium, the Big House, in Ann Arbor

Photo: Lectrician2, CC BY-SA 4.0

A night game at Western Michigan's Waldo Stadium in Kalamazoo, seen from the band section

Photo: Whippdog, CC BY-SA 4.0

Big brother and little brother: Michigan Stadium in Ann Arbor, where the game was played, and Western Michigan's Waldo Stadium in Kalamazoo.

The paradox in numbers

The growing university, the slower market

Ryan set up the question: are college towns really recession-proof? Michigan has two good test cases about 100 miles apart. Ann Arbor is home to the University of Michigan, which has grown every year to a record 53,488 students. Kalamazoo is home to Western Michigan University, which has lost more than a quarter of its students since 2017.

If the university drove the housing market, Ann Arbor would be winning easily. It isn't. Over ten years, Kalamazoo's typical home value has risen faster, and over the last year its median sale price went up 12% while Ann Arbor's went down 7%.

Ann Arbor

University
Michigan, 53,488 students
Enrollment since fall 2017
+16%
Metro population, 2025
370,000
Median sale price, Jul–Sep
$459,781
Change, 1 yr
−6.9%
Months of supply
3.7
Median days on market
44

Kalamazoo

University
Western Michigan, 16,696
Enrollment since fall 2017
−27%
Metro population, 2025
264,000
Median sale price, Jul–Sep
$223,594
Change, 1 yr
+12.1%
Months of supply
2.6
Median days on market
15

One university grew, the other shrank

Fall headcount enrollment, all students

  • University of Michigan (Ann Arbor)
  • Western Michigan University
View as table
University of Michigan (Ann Arbor)Western Michigan University
Fall 201746,00222,893
Fall 202553,48817,331
Fall 2026–16,696
Michigan's Ann Arbor campus grew 16% from fall 2017 to fall 2025; its official fall 2026 count isn't out yet. Western Michigan fell 24% to fall 2025 and 27% to its preliminary fall 2026 count. Sources: University of Michigan, Western Michigan University, and the Michigan Association of State Universities' fall 2026 preliminary report via WWMT.

Kalamazoo has out-appreciated Ann Arbor for a decade

Zillow typical home value, indexed to 100 in January 2016

  • Kalamazoo metro
  • Ann Arbor metro
  • United States
View as table
MonthKalamazoo metroAnn Arbor metroUnited States
Jan 2016100.0100.0100.0
Jan 2017103.8104.8105.5
Jan 2018111.2111.8112.3
Jan 2019118.3119.2118.6
Jan 2020125.8124.4124.6
Jan 2021139.0130.6137.5
Jan 2022155.9140.6159.4
Jan 2023163.6149.0172.1
Jan 2024171.3154.3177.5
Jan 2025179.2161.3182.3
Jan 2026185.3164.3182.6
Sep 2026189.1165.5183.4
From September 2016 to September 2026, Kalamazoo's typical home value rose 83%, the nation's 77% and Ann Arbor's 61%. Ann Arbor's peaked in April 2026. Ryan called Kalamazoo's edge "slightly stronger"; over ten years it's about 22 points. Source: Zillow Home Value Index (all homes, middle tier, smoothed and seasonally adjusted), through September 2026.
MeasureAnn ArborKalamazoo
The university
Fall enrollment, latest53,488 (2025)16,696 (2026, prelim.)
Change since fall 2017+16.3%−27.1%
The people
Metro population, 2025370,214263,795
Metro payroll jobs, Sep 2026232,100131,400
Jobs change, 10 yr+6.6%+2.8%
City median household income$82,212$52,272
City adults with a bachelor's or higher77.9%38.5%
City households that rent54.5%57.7%
The market (city, Jul–Sep 2026)
Median sale price$459,781−6.9% yr$223,594+12.1% yr
Median price per sq ft, 1 yr−5.0%−9.7%
Price-to-income ratio5.64.3
Homes for sale, 1 yr+29.1%+32.7%
Pending sales, 1 yr−15.8%−2.8%
Months of supply3.72.6
Median days on market4415
Sale-to-list ratio98.8%96.9%
Listings with a price cut39.5%40.4%
Zillow typical home value, 1 yr (city ZIPs)+2.6%+5.1%
Zillow typical home value, 10 yr (city ZIPs)+62.1%+107.8%
HousingGauge score, week of Oct 2642 · RED45 · YELLOW

Sources: university enrollment releases; Census Bureau population estimates and BLS payrolls via FRED; American Community Survey 2020–2024 (city); Redfin, three months ending September 2026 (city of Ann Arbor, city of Kalamazoo); Zillow ZHVI. Price-to-income is the median sale price divided by the city's median household income.

Read the fine print

Down 7%, or up 3%?

The headline numbers on air are right: Redfin's median sale price for the city of Ann Arbor is $459,781, down 6.9% from a year earlier, and Kalamazoo's is $223,594, up 12.1%. But a median sale price tracks whichever homes happened to sell, so it moves when the mix changes.

Look at the same year two other ways and the gap narrows. Price per square foot fell in both cities, and fell more in Kalamazoo (−9.7%) than in Ann Arbor (−5.0%), which means larger homes made up more of Kalamazoo's sales this summer. Zillow's typical home value, which follows the same homes over time, has both cities still rising: Ann Arbor's city ZIP codes up 2.6% and Kalamazoo's up 5.1%.

So Kalamazoo is still the stronger market, but by a few points, not nineteen. Ann Arbor isn't crashing; it's stalling, with 29% more homes for sale than a year ago, pending sales down 16%, and price cuts on 39% of listings.

Three ways to measure the same year

Change from a year earlier, city of Ann Arbor vs. city of Kalamazoo

  • Ann Arbor
  • Kalamazoo
View as table
Ann ArborKalamazoo
Median sale price−6.9%+12.1%
Price per sq ft−5.0%−9.7%
Typical home value+2.6%+5.1%
The first two are Redfin sales for the three months ending September 2026. Typical home value is Zillow's index for the city ZIP codes (Ann Arbor: 48103, 48104, 48105, 48108; Kalamazoo: 49001, 49006, 49007, 49008, 49048), September 2026.

Ann Arbor

The left-brain pick

Near the end of COVID, Chris and his wife were in the Bay Area with young kids, smoke from the fires in the air, and about half a million dollars of equity in their house. So they did what HousingGauge does: scored the whole country on what they cared about. Schools. Walkability ("I want to walk to the coffee shop. I want to be able to walk the kids to the school"). Amenities, nature, even a hedge on climate. "Ann Arbor won hands down."

It looked like an early Austin: a great university, a river, a downtown everyone who has lived there is proud of. They bought a house sight unseen, and for that one they let the right brain choose the street over the price per square foot. Then family won out and they moved to Dallas–Fort Worth instead.

The house became a rental, and it has been the easy one. The mortgage is an adjustable rate under 3%, fixed for about five years with a cap on how far it can rise. The tenants are PhD students who stay two or three years and don't damage anything, and the property manager lines up the next one months ahead, so it has never sat empty. It covers its own costs, maintenance included. It appreciated for four years and gave some back in the last one: Chris figures it's worth about 96% of what it was a year ago.

Main Street in downtown Ann Arbor at night, at William Street

Photo: Dwight Burdette, CC BY 3.0

Main Street, Ann Arbor: the walkable downtown that won the family spreadsheet.

Today HousingGauge scores the city of Ann Arbor 42, RED: homes for sale are up 29% on the year, 3.7 months of supply, and price cuts on 39% of listings. Inside the city, though, Zillow's index has every ZIP code within 1% of its peak. The softness is in what's selling, not yet in what homes are worth.

ZIP codeTypical value1 yr5 yr10 yrFrom peak
City of Ann Arbor
Central, Burns Park48104$563K+3.1%+23.2%+59.2%−0.7%
Old West Side, west48103$517K+3.3%+23.1%+60.4%At peak
North side48105$545K+2.3%+21.0%+62.1%−0.9%
South side48108$434K+1.5%+24.6%+66.9%−0.6%
Around it
Ypsilanti48197$342K+1.0%+21.9%+77.9%−0.3%
Ypsilanti east48198$223K−3.2%+20.7%+100.7%−3.4%
Saline48176$465K+2.5%+16.7%+49.8%At peak
Dexter48130$508K+3.6%+5.0%+33.0%At peak
Benchmarks
Ann Arbor city ZIPs48103, 48104, 48105, 48108–+2.6%+22.9%+62.1%–
Ann Arbor metro$412K+2.4%+19.5%+61.0%−0.1%
United States$366K+1.2%+19.7%+77.4%At peak

Zillow Home Value Index (all homes, middle tier, smoothed and seasonally adjusted), September 2026. The city rows are equal-weighted groups of the ZIP codes listed, the same groups the predictions below are graded on.

Kalamazoo

Nine doors and a banjo

Chris first saw Kalamazoo 22 years ago as an engineering intern at Flowserve's plant, which makes mechanical seals that keep industrial pumps from leaking. Coming from Texas, the summer felt European: he biked from his temporary housing on the southwest side to downtown and back, took up running, read a lot, and spent weekends at the dueling-piano bar. (On the work: "I don't think they got any value out of me.")

About 15 years later, his Castro Valley house had gone from $640,000 to $800,000, so he took out a home equity line of credit and went looking for somewhere to use it. Kalamazoo came up because it was cheap: duplexes for $75,000. He paid $102,000 for a nicer one, then $120,000 for a triplex, then bought a fourplex. At the peak he had nine doors.

The lessons came fast. He bought the first duplex before he had a property manager and gave tenants his own phone number, so the requests came straight to him: lower rent, a late payment, a missed month. "If I let you not pay rent, guess what? I'm essentially paying your rent." Cheap property and drama travel together, he says: the lower the rent, the closer the tenants are to the edge. Running two of the fourplex units as Airbnbs from California didn't work either. When the cleaner doesn't show up, "I can't jump on a plane to go change a bed."

He sold all of it. On air he put the profit at about $50,000; afterward he corrected that. The fourplex alone sold for a $200,000 profit, so the nine doors made him well over $200,000. The return was strong. The problem was the dollars per hour: the drama and the time it took.

Worst case, as Chris saw it
−$25,000
Buy at $100K, sell at $75K
Best case
Mailbox money
Plus the education
What he made
$200,000+
The fourplex alone; he said $50K on air

That asymmetry is why Chris still recommends a market like Kalamazoo for a first deal: "The worst that can happen is I lose $25,000." Starting with a Beverly Hills deal is how people end up underwater. And if a bank won't lend you the money, "that should be a red flag to you yourself."

Aircraft on display inside the Air Zoo aerospace museum near Kalamazoo

Photo: Michael Barera, CC BY-SA 4.0

Gibson's Kalamazoo factory floor in 1936, and the Air Zoo, the aviation museum Chris toured.

Local flavor. Chris bought his first banjo in Kalamazoo, the week after a company pontoon-boat outing with a banjo player on board. Fitting, Ryan pointed out: Kalamazoo is where Gibson started making guitars and mandolins in 1902. Gibson moved production to Nashville in the 1980s, and a group of former employees kept building guitars in the old Parsons Street factory as Heritage Guitar. Ryan's other pick, the Gilmore Car Museum in Hickory Corners, bills itself as the largest auto museum in North America. Chris missed it, but he did make it to the Air Zoo.

ZIP codeTypical value1 yr5 yr10 yrFrom peak
City of Kalamazoo
Downtown, Northside, Vine49007$128K+8.7%+34.3%+140.4%At peak
Edison, Milwood, east side49001$167K+3.4%+31.2%+121.9%−0.1%
Eastwood, Comstock49048$198K+3.7%+28.2%+100.3%At peak
West side near WMU49006$241K+5.7%+28.8%+92.6%At peak
Winchell, Oakwood, south49008$248K+4.0%+26.4%+88.1%At peak
Around it
Oshtemo, Texas Township49009$370K+2.6%+18.6%+65.6%At peak
Portage north49002$273K+4.3%+23.9%+83.0%At peak
Portage south49024$308K+4.7%+22.9%+78.3%At peak
Benchmarks
Kalamazoo city ZIPs49001, 49006, 49007, 49008, 49048–+5.1%+29.7%+107.8%–
Kalamazoo metro$274K+4.4%+24.2%+83.3%At peak
United States$366K+1.2%+19.7%+77.4%At peak

Zillow Home Value Index (all homes, middle tier, smoothed and seasonally adjusted), September 2026. The city rows are equal-weighted groups of the ZIP codes listed, the same groups the predictions below are graded on. The cheapest ZIP codes rose the most: 49007's typical value is about $128,000 after gaining 140% in ten years.

So why?

It's the price, not the payrolls

Chris's explanation is the fundamentals: jobs and price. Kalamazoo has Stryker's headquarters, a big Pfizer manufacturing plant in Portage, and a life-sciences base he thinks is relatively insulated from AI. Ann Arbor, in his view, is full of people who moved there to work remotely for tech companies, which is exactly the job that's being cut now. "I was almost one of those people. And guess what? Had I done that, I'd probably be laid off right now."

The payroll data only half agrees. Over ten years, Ann Arbor actually added more jobs than Kalamazoo (+6.6% vs. +2.8%), and Kalamazoo still has fewer jobs than before the pandemic (−0.3%). In the last year Ann Arbor's payrolls rose +0.4% and Kalamazoo's changed −0.5%. Payroll counts can't show a remote worker's employer, so this doesn't test the AI theory either way.

What the data does back is the price half. A typical Kalamazoo sale costs 4.3 years of the city's median household income; in Ann Arbor it's 5.6. That's Chris's other point: in Kalamazoo, people with modest incomes can still buy, and cheap places have the most room to run. Ten years ago you could buy a home in Kalamazoo's 49007 for about $53,000. Today it's about $128,000.

HousingGauge didn't cover Kalamazoo when the episode was recorded. It does now: Kalamazoo scores 45, YELLOW, just ahead of Ann Arbor at 42, RED, with ten years of weekly history.

Ann Arbor added more jobs, and still lost the price race

Payroll jobs, indexed to 100 in January 2016

  • Ann Arbor metro
  • Kalamazoo metro
  • United States
View as table
MonthAnn Arbor metroKalamazoo metroUnited States
Jan 2016100.0100.0100.0
Jan 2017102.3102.3101.7
Jan 2018104.4103.2103.1
Jan 2019105.4104.7104.8
Jan 2020106.9105.2106.2
Jan 202197.695.799.8
Jan 2022103.2101.0104.7
Jan 2023106.0103.7108.1
Jan 2024107.6104.9109.7
Jan 2025108.2106.2110.5
Jan 2026107.9105.4110.7
Sep 2026108.8105.2111.1
Both metros have trailed the nation's job growth since 2016. Source: BLS Current Employment Statistics, total nonfarm, seasonally adjusted, via FRED, through September 2026.

Show notes

The Kalamazoo Promise

Ryan asked about the Kalamazoo Promise, and Chris called it a double-edged sword. The facts: in November 2005, anonymous donors promised to pay college tuition for graduates of Kalamazoo Public Schools. A student who attended from kindergarten through 12th grade gets 100%; one who started in 9th grade gets 65%; the share rises with each year in between. It covers Michigan's public universities and community colleges, and it later added private colleges in the state. Since April 2026, community college is covered at 100% for every eligible student.

The idea was to pull families into a city that was losing them. The city of Kalamazoo had about 77,000 residents in 2000 and about 73,600 in 2020, so it didn't reverse the slide, though the metro around it has grown slightly. Chris remembers the city as less safe and more chaotic when he sold than it was 20 years earlier, but says the gesture was good, "giving people an opportunity they wouldn't have otherwise had." Whether the Promise was a net positive for housing is a bigger question than one episode, and Chris promised a deeper look.

Show notes

Did Kalamazoo get less safe?

Chris: "I think crime in Kalamazoo is way up, or it was." We checked 26 years of FBI data for the city's Department of Public Safety, and the answer is "it was," for violent crime.

When Chris interned there around 2004, Kalamazoo recorded 676 violent crimes per 100,000 residents, its lowest rate since at least 2000. The rate climbed through the 2010s and peaked at 1,600 in 2021, more than double. Since then it has fallen every year but one, to 1,084 in 2025, about where it was in 2000. Property crime tells a different story: it fell by more than half, from 6,700 per 100,000 in 2000 to 2,948 in 2025.

Kalamazoo's violent crime rate is still about three times the nation's and three to four times Ann Arbor's. That is part of what Chris means by drama, and part of why the same dollar buys so much more house there.

Violent crime in Kalamazoo doubled, then fell back

Violent crimes reported per 100,000 residents, 2000–2025

  • Kalamazoo (city)
  • Ann Arbor (city)
  • United States
View as table
YearKalamazoo (city)Ann Arbor (city)United States
20001,054266534
20011,110307530
20021,092261513
2003–259494
2004676232479
2005811314483
20061,016308487
20071,169264478
20081,030265464
2009981233437
2010964251408
2011822234390
2012896201391
20131,064215378
20141,165166374
20151,133193385
20161,212179400
20171,174219398
20181,351231385
20191,255257381
20201,440252399
20211,600295361
20221,519312398
20231,258314386
20241,289311363
20251,084297330
Murder, rape, robbery and aggravated assault reported by the Kalamazoo Department of Public Safety and the Ann Arbor Police Department. Kalamazoo reported only ten months of 2003, so that year is left out. 2026 figures aren't published yet. Source: FBI Uniform Crime Reporting Program via the Crime Data Explorer.

Property crime fell by more than half

Property crimes reported per 100,000 residents, 2000–2025

  • Kalamazoo (city)
  • Ann Arbor (city)
  • United States
View as table
YearKalamazoo (city)Ann Arbor (city)United States
20006,7003,2563,752
20017,0653,0943,802
20027,1043,0023,738
2003–2,9113,704
20045,4892,7153,599
20056,1882,9993,518
20066,9102,6103,397
20076,3322,4813,316
20085,9672,7353,252
20096,0912,5863,077
20104,8102,6042,963
20114,4822,2522,926
20124,2662,3982,881
20134,1412,1832,759
20143,8641,8902,592
20153,5702,0072,495
20164,2561,7562,469
20174,1571,7372,372
20185,1371,5942,207
20194,7761,7392,109
20204,9011,3451,955
20214,4961,4491,762
20224,5791,7351,998
20234,2381,7781,950
20243,5081,7451,767
20252,9481,7071,552
Burglary, larceny-theft, motor vehicle theft and arson. Source: FBI Uniform Crime Reporting Program via the Crime Data Explorer.

Where they stand

Live in Ann Arbor, invest in Kalamazoo

Ryan: live in Ann Arbor, invest in Kalamazoo. Ann Arbor is the better place to buy a home and raise a family. Kalamazoo is the better place to invest: at today's prices, positive cash flow, decent tenants in a solid neighborhood, and appreciation upside. Real estate is illiquid, so think five years at minimum and ten or more ideally. Long term, he's bullish on both.

Chris: cash is king, for now. By the numbers, Kalamazoo will outperform: "It's already at the floor. I don't think it can go down much more than it already has." He isn't buying either one. He's holding the Ann Arbor house, with its great rate, and building "the gunpowder" for when the national market turns green. Ann Arbor has too much inventory, too many price cuts and rates that are still too high, and AI is making things complicated. "Three years from now will be a great time to be buying Ann Arbor."

Sources and credits

  • Home values: Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI), all homes, middle tier, smoothed and seasonally adjusted, metro and ZIP code, through September 2026.
  • Market conditions: Redfin data for the three months ending September 2026 (city) and September 2026 (metro); HousingGauge score for Ann Arbor, week of October 26, 2026.
  • Population, payrolls: U.S. Census Bureau and Bureau of Labor Statistics via FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. Income, education and renters: American Community Survey 5-year estimates, 2020–2024.
  • Enrollment: University of Michigan and Western Michigan University releases; Michigan Association of State Universities fall 2026 preliminary report via WWMT.
  • The game: CBS Sports, Sports Illustrated, On3, Yahoo Sports.
  • Kalamazoo Promise: Education Next and WMUK.
  • Crime: FBI Uniform Crime Reporting Program, offenses known to law enforcement, via the Crime Data Explorer, 2000–2025.
  • Photos via Wikimedia Commons: Lectrician2 (CC BY-SA 4.0), Whippdog (CC BY-SA 4.0), Dwight Burdette (CC BY 3.0), Mamie Austin / Kalamazoo Public Library (public domain), Michael Barera (CC BY-SA 4.0).

Predictions made in this episode

Scorecard →

Transcript

Machine transcript, with names corrected.

Chris:00:01 Hey, what's up?

Ryan:00:03 Hey brother, how are you? Good, Yeah. So.

Chris:00:05 Good, good. episode three. So we're talking

about Ann Arbor, Kalamazoo, college towns. but how you been, man?

Ryan:00:16 Yeah, been great. Yeah, happy Friday.

Chris:00:19 Happy Friday.

Ryan:00:20 Halloween Eve, huh? You got any plans for Halloween?

Chris:00:25 we're gonna do the kid thing, you know, go walk around, do you know, get the kids with the pillowcases and I've got seventh grade daughter

Ryan:00:30 The pillowcase.

Chris:00:33 now, so I think she'll I think she wants to go, you know, do the big kid thing away from us, which that'll be interesting and you know Yeah, she wants

Ryan:00:39 Okay, she's leaving mom and dad to go hang out with their buddies.

Chris:00:42 to go hang out with her her friends and kinda do the the independent thing, and that'll be with the other two kind of somewhere somewhat

Ryan:00:49 Yeah.

Chris:00:49 around them, but give them a little bit of space too. how about you?

Ryan:00:52 Yeah,

Chris:00:54 What are you guys doing?

Ryan:00:54 Yeah,

so same thing. mean, got a freshman in high school, so he doesn't want to trick or treat with mom and dad anymore, unfortunately. But yeah, I'll probably sit on the driveway and pass out candy to kids in the neighborhood. And

Chris:01:09 Cool.

Ryan:01:09 I don't have a costume yet, but maybe grab one real quick and find something for the dog.

Chris:01:15 Get fake blood and just put it on you somewhere and it's like done.

Ryan:01:16 Some fake blood. Yeah.

think when I was a kid, I was a punk rocker like every year. Just spray paint your hair and wear

Chris:01:23 Yeah.

Ryan:01:24 some ripped clothes. Yeah, just rocking and rolling. Yeah, episode three, brother. We have the number one podcast for real estate in all of the land.

And we're learning here, right? Episode one, little shaky, but we made it happen. Episode two got a little bit better, and now here we are, episode three. So what have we learned so far? mean, what do you think we can do to improve this podcast?

Chris:01:53 Yeah, yeah. So I think

So I think episode one, we learned can we do it and the tools that we need to do it. I think we learned a lot about that. and I think we're still learning about lighting and Wi-Fi connectivity and audio. Like my I didn't have my headset working today, so audio may be a little bit messed up.

last week I think we learned, how to how do I do this on my phone? Like if I am, somewhere, you know, outside of my house or or you know, where I normally am, can we do this kind of on the fly, like with no internet connection?

I think last week we said we want to learn about how to get a guest on. So that was our hope.

Right. that we're gonna have a guest on on episode three. and I would say we learned some things over the past week. Unfortunately, I don't think we're gonna have a guest today. I mean, I know we're not gonna have a guest. Nobody nobody responded to all my emails. Yeah. Yeah. Maybe maybe

Ryan:02:42 You never know, you never know.

Chris:02:46 maybe somebody will just randomly join. but what we did learn, like how to do email campaigns and how to use, you know, Claude to generate lists of people that look interesting.

automatically, write, crafted emails based on, housing gauge data that may be of interest to them. how to send, you know, and then

Ryan:03:06 Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

Chris:03:07 how to do this all for free, right? Like, cause right now we're still in learning mode, like you said. how do we do this for free? So everything I'm doing, I'm like, if it costs five bucks, is there another way? Right. So so that that's been a really kind of fun experiment and fun, fun constraint. And it's amazing how much you can do for free. I mean, like all the data on housinggauge.com.

All the emails we're sending

Ryan:03:27 Yeah.

Chris:03:28 out, and and then then, for the things that really truly add value, maybe spend seven bucks here, seven bucks there. But it's been amazing what we can do for free,

Ryan:03:37 Yeah, well I appreciate you brother because as I am not doing much behind the scenes. You came up with the idea for the pod. You sent me all the materials and show notes. You've done all the technology, the websites, edited the pod, right? Put it up on Spotify and all the different outlets. I just show up and ask the questions. So I really appreciate what you're doing.

Chris:04:00 No man, appreciate you. thanks for thanks for going on the journey. It's like, yeah, I think it it's you you you keep it fun. in it in yeah. Yeah, I know. Well that's the thing, right? Like

Ryan:04:04 Yeah, no, it's fun. so, yeah, so I am here to entertain and hang out with you, brother, but you are working hard behind the scenes.

Chris:04:14 we talk about this stuff anyways. So it's like, hey, we can release something, a conversation we're gonna have naturally. So that's what this is. it's it's a very low amount of effort and investment for something we're already doing.

And yeah, so so let's just maybe we'll jump into it.

Ryan:04:30 Yeah, so why don't I set the kind of scene for the listeners, right? All of our listeners across the land. yeah, so you sent me some show notes and I think we're going to head to Michigan, right? And we're going to compare two college towns, Ann Arbor and Kalamazoo. And I think the foundation of this episode and the question that we're going to ask is,

are college towns really recession proof, right? And I think a lot of investors think they know the answer and we're gonna dive into it. But before we break it down, let's kind of set the stage here. We're gonna look at Ann Arbor first and it's home to the University of Michigan, right? One of the most recognizable universities in the country. It's about 40 miles west of Detroit, right? Detroit being the largest city in Michigan.

It has roughly 370,000 people in the metropolitan area. And then the median home sale price is 460,000, right? So much higher than the national average.

Chris:05:32 And I'll make a part of the natural.

Ryan:05:35 And then we have Kalamazoo, right? 100 miles west of Ann Arbor. So it's kind of in the same area, roughly, right? And it's home to Western Michigan University, right? So has a rich history there. They have a big medical.

Chris:05:39 It's only two asked for the issue first. Go Broncos.

Ryan:05:51 Go Broncos, yeah. So,

Chris:05:51 Yeah.

Ryan:05:53 a strong medical presence, right? And then the metropolitan area is roughly $264,000. And then the median home price is around $224,000. So, about half of Ann Arbor, right? So, it's a much more affordable kind of town. And...

Here's where things get interesting, and I think this is going to be at the heart of our discussion. The University of Michigan's enrollment has grown nearly 20 % since 2017.

Chris:06:24 Since two thousand seventeen.

Ryan:06:27 And Western Michigan's enrollment has actually declined 27%. So it's declined quite a bit.

Chris:06:29 didn't decline that's actually decline seven percent. So decline quite a bit.

Ryan:06:36 so despite those

Chris:06:37 Right.

Ryan:06:38 two paths from the university's perspective,

Chris:06:40 With the currency perspective,

Ryan:06:41 Kalamazoo has seen a slightly stronger home price appreciation

Chris:06:42 that's it, which is offerable.

Ryan:06:46 over the past decade. And Chris, you've invested in both markets and here's what I want to know, So does being in a great

Chris:06:51 I want to know that.

Ryan:06:57 college town kind of translate to a great real estate investment? Or are we giving the universities a little too much credit here?

Chris:07:05 Yeah, that's the hypothesis. I I think that was the hypothesis when I invested in both of those locations that hey, there's university here, right? that should be a safe investment. There's some stability, should be a fun place to visit, you know, because I I I live in California. but first the scandal.

So, so Michigan versus Western Michigan. They played this year. Did did you did

Ryan:07:24 It's a scandal. We always got to start with a scandal.

Chris:07:28 you see that? Do you watch or hear about that game? The Western Michigan versus Michigan. I think it was the first game of the season. It was at Michigan.

Ryan:07:34 No, what happened?

Chris:07:35 Western Michigan was winning. time ran out. Game over. Western Michigan wins. And it was Michigan was on the, I don't know, 40 yard line or something like that. So game over, right? Literally the clock went to zero.

Ryan:07:47 Yeah.

Ouch. Okay.

Chris:07:50 Somehow the ref said,

no, put a one second back on because the clock on the stadium is wrong, and the clock that the t television viewers are watching are wrong. There's some other clock that nobody sees. So put one second on there. Michigan throws

Ryan:08:01 Hahaha

Chris:08:02 a Hail Mary, wins the game. Western Michigan Broncos almost beat

Ryan:08:05 Wow

Chris:08:07 the legendary Wolverines. Anyways, that was a scandal. It was a scandal this year. So

Ryan:08:10 Yeah. So the ref got involved,

put an extra second on the clock, they threw a Hail Mary and won the game.

Chris:08:17 Yeah, this is like little brother's about

to beat up Little Brothers about to beat up Big Brother. That was a big scandal that whole week. Anyways, all right, so let's go back to man, it was it Yeah, that was I

Ryan:08:26 I missed that. did not see that and I wish I had. How does that

make you feel? How does that make you feel,

Chris:08:35 it I w I I didn't I didn't go to either university, but you know, you always root for the the underdog, right? And so especially knowing Kalamazoo's

Ryan:08:42 Yeah.

Chris:08:43 story and knowing both universities and knowing, like you said, the enrollments down, like that could have been a good thing for Western Michigan. That could have been a fun little ego boost. I was obviously rooting for

Ryan:08:53 yeah.

Chris:08:53 the Broncos that game, but you know, I like the Wolverines too. Anyways, yeah, back to your

Ryan:08:58 Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Chris:08:59 back to your question.

Yeah, y the hypothesis for a long time has been, college towns should be stable, should have it should be attracting industry into some of those places too, because you have a lot of students, you know, especially the best students, you know, they want to stay there. And so it can attract jobs. It's kind of supply and demand. You can get some high talent,

for maybe undermarket. So I think about I went to University of Texas undergrad. And at the time, this is 25 years ago, it was a college town, right? it was the city wasn't as big as it is today. So as a as a proportion of the of the city, the university, which is 50,000 people, it's a very big university. there's

Ryan:09:37 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Chris:09:38 no college there's no no major league teams or anything like that, no professional sports. Everything was centered around the university. It was a university town, high percentage of student to non-student ratio, but there were no jobs.

And so, after university, it's like you either move to Houston or Dallas Fort Worth because those are where the jobs are. And and the ratio of,

Ryan:09:56 Yeah.

Chris:09:56 jobs per university student is lower in those towns, in those cities. But you know, Austin was a university town. Now that's changed and it's grown. And I don't know what the metro

Ryan:10:05 Yeah.

Chris:10:06 area is now, but it's it's much, much bigger than it was then. There's actually a lot of jobs there now. So it's not as much of a university town as it was back then. But these

But you but that's the hypothesis is that university towns attract stability in markets, rents can be higher. if you're an investor, it's a great spot from from the perspective of you have a lot of people that have access to money, aka their parents are helping them pay for rent, or you know, maybe they have

student loans to help pay for rent. They've got some way to that capital, but they can't qualify to buy a home themselves and they're transient, so they don't necessarily want to buy a home themselves. So it's a good investment

Ryan:10:38 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Chris:10:39 location to keeps prices, in some university towns lower than what you know you might see in other places where people are making money, but you get higher returns. and so that was kind of the hypothesis, you know, when I went in back in the day and and invested in Kalamazoo and then and then later invested in Ann Arbor.

but yeah, it that was a hypothesis back then, was like university towns are good and Michigan I liked just because of the relative affordability versus some of the other places.

Ryan:11:09 Yeah, no, that's great. Yeah, and let's deep dive into Ann Arbor. And again, that was a place where you, I mean, you were thinking about moving out there, right? Not only just investing in the community, but actually moving out there. And Ann Arbor is just this kind of cool place, right? Think of like Berkeley meets a small kind of Midwest college town, right? They have the historical neighborhoods.

a beautiful university and campus. have restaurants. It's a hub

Chris:11:39 Yeah.

Ryan:11:40 for research institutions. There's a bunch of highly educated residents that live there and of this major medical kind of hub. So walk us through, mean, you looked at the entire country, right? You and your wife kind of did this analysis and you circled Ann Arbor and you said, you know what, let's actually, we're gonna move here, right? We're gonna raise our family in Ann Arbor.

Talk us through that process and ultimately, you shared that you went to Texas and came back to California. You live in California

Chris:12:08 Yeah.

Ryan:12:09 now. You didn't end up living there and moving your family there, but you still have real estate there. But at one point you thought, hey, this is going

Chris:12:18 Okay.

Ryan:12:18 to be home for my family. This is where I want

Chris:12:21 Yeah.

Ryan:12:21 to be. So walk us through that and tell us a little bit about that process.

Chris:12:27 kind of tail end of COVID. we're in the Bay Area, it's expensive, got kids, wife and I were kind of like, okay, this might be an opportunity. I think at the time, you know, there's some fires going on around the Bay Area and everything was smoky.

We can s we we can sell our house, make a half million dollars and plow it into something else. So we're like, okay, well let's let's let's scour the the the country eating the that's part of HousingGauge, right? this is something I do anyways, I've been doing it for years, something you do. Like there's we have all this data, access to data. So this was we went through this exercise.

Where in the country is the best place to live given the factors that we care about as a as a family of young children. so schools

Ryan:13:02 Yeah.

Chris:13:02 obviously were important. you know, walkability. We really like to walk. We like to have access to, amenities that we can like, I want to walk to the coffee shop. I want to be able to walk the kids to the school

So as we look at a lot of places, I'm from Dallas, Fort Worth, and that's ultimately what we what won because I have family and there's free babysitting and things like that, which is hard, hard

Ryan:13:22 Hahaha

Chris:13:23 to hard to turn down. but you know what what the Yeah, but Ann Arbor originally won

Ryan:13:25 Yeah, it's nice to be close to your folks and yeah, and where you grew up.

Chris:13:32 one on the left brain. So you know your logical brain, you know, when I look at all the factors that I say I care about.

Ryan:13:40 Mm-hmm.

Chris:13:41 Ann Arbor won hands down, and everyone I've ever spoken to that's lived there, whether they went to school there, I mean, they are all just, you know, proud of.

having spent time in Ann Arbor, they also it seems like what Austin might have been when people talk about its heyday back in the day when it was like in the 1980s or

Ryan:13:57 Yeah.

Chris:13:58 1990s before I was even there. so I'm like, okay, this has the potential to be an Austin. It's got, you know, a good university, it's got, you know, good amenities, if it, you know, and it's it's gonna have that pressure, to grow. It's gets beautiful. It's got, you know, river running down,

On the north side, it's it's got access to to nature. if you and then the other pieces, if you think about global warming, it could be actually be set up in a somewhat okay position from that perspective because it's cold, right? that's the complaint.

Ryan:14:27 You're thinking of all the angles.

Chris:14:28 But if there's a global warming,

So we actually went through this whole process, we got with an agent, we bought a house, sight unseen, you know, like obviously

Ryan:14:35 Yeah.

Chris:14:36 you know, we we did all the analysis. We're like, hey, this is a good deal. this is the house we were going to live in.

I didn't care as much about the metrics. I was like, I want it to look for you, I want to be in the right area. I don't care about the price per square foot as much. I want I want the the intangibles. and so we really, the left brain said, Ann Arbor's the place for your family. Then when we actually made the strike, we kind of went to our right brain and said, okay, well, where do we actually want to spend our time? And so then we bought that house, you know. So we bought the house that, you know, may have been.

not the cheapest. but it was a place that we thought, hey, we could spend our time here, we could live here. as we already said, after we bought that house, reconsidered and decided to move to Texas because of family. the other good thing about it was it it cash flowed like out the gates. And the other piece was our interest rate was like, you know, sub three.

Still a sub three. I I didn't I did

Ryan:15:30 Yeah, so...

Chris:15:31 an adjustable rate and we can talk through that if you want, but it was like an adjustable rate that was essentially fixed for some number of years. I think it was fixed for like five years, and then and then it could go up some amount up to a and it had a ceiling though. So I was protected and I you know, and so that was a calculated play that's a whole different deal around like the financing perspective.

Ryan:15:52 Yeah, no, but

it's big part of the decision making process, right?

Chris:15:56 Yeah.

Ryan:15:57 You get an excellent interest rate, you found a home that you love, and you're actually thinking about moving there, right? And yeah, if you can kind of lock in that interest rate for five or seven years, that's a big factor. So go ahead.

Chris:16:10 Yeah. Yeah. And and then and then

with that, all that being said, when we decided to move to Texas instead of moving to Ann Arbor, it was cash flowing. So it wasn't like I was having to pay for two homes. It was actually holding steady. I wouldn't say it was necessarily bringing in a bunch of cash, for us, but it was it was like, Hey, I don't have to do anything and it's essentially paying for itself, even with the maintenance costs and everything. And that was the other

Thing is, and I can't speak for all the city, but and we can contrast it to Kalamazoo in a minute, but the tenants have been awesome, right? So you asked one of the questions you asked is what is the tenant like? Well, they're like PhD students, they live there for two or three years, and I, they're hassle free and they they don't damage the property, or I don't have drama, right? they're they're good tenants. they're the

Ryan:17:01 Yeah.

Chris:17:02 you know, so

That's been amazing. That the property manager has been amazing. They're they're they're proactive. They like six months before somebody leaves, or even before, they're thinking about what the next step is. and so I don't

Ryan:17:16 Yeah.

Chris:17:16 c they're practically coming to me. And so therefore, you know, it's really never been vacant. We have good tenants that are paying.

enough to where I don't lose any money on the house. It's appreciated since we bought it,

it's done well over the last five years, but it's, you know, the last year it's yeah, I think the whole city's been down. Yeah. Yeah.

Ryan:17:32 interest rates might be again weighing on everybody,

right?

Chris:17:35 Kalamazoo is a very different town, Like you

it it's run down. You know, at least

Ryan:17:40 Hehehehe

Chris:17:41 So I did my internship in college in Kalamazoo

plant there.

Ryan:17:45 on.

Let's give the audience a little context. Okay, so what year is this and what kind of intern were you? Were you an intern that showed up to work on time, did a great job, or did you out late the night before partying

Chris:17:58 this was twenty-two years ago. Yeah, so I'm I'm

Ryan:17:59 Christopher Longhorn Anderson is an intern in Kalamazoo.

Chris:18:04 yeah, so so yeah, so it's very different than than what I'd grown up grown up with in Texas.

it was in the summer. So, you know, obviously that was a nice time of year versus, you know, everyone's

Ryan:18:14 Yep.

Chris:18:14 like, you know, winters are harsh, but like from my my perspective, you know, I'm coming from Texas where summers are brutal. I'm like, this place is awesome, you know. and and I didn't know anybody and

Ryan:18:22 Yeah, I'm gonna move here.

I'm gonna buy some real estate here one day, right?

Chris:18:27 Yeah, I didn't at that time

I that was not even anything I was thinking about. But it was funny. Yeah, it but it was it was it was interesting because it's just very different. it

Ryan:18:39 Yeah.

Chris:18:39 and and and so the company was Flowserve makes things like pumps and valves and things like that. In this particular factory they make mechanical seals, which can be very expensive for

very highly engineered. And I was an engineering major, so I was an engineering intern, so, you know, these seals keep pumps from leaking, you know, in the sense of like, say, you're doing a carcinogen chemical and a leak

Ryan:19:02 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Chris:19:03 can be really bad.

TMI on that side of things. that was my exposure to Kalamazoo at that time. And what I loved about that city at that time

was how bikeable it was. So I, lived on the southwest side. They, essentially had a temporary housing situation for me. It was paid for and I just showed up. I brought my bicycle and I could bike around town. it felt small that I could bike to downtown and back. And it just felt everything felt more European to me at the time because I was, coming from Texas, everything was sprawling. Everything felt old.

and so that felt nice. It felt quaint. There was a university there, so on the weekend I could go to the dueling piano bar and you know, kind of like listen

Ryan:19:39 Hahaha!

Chris:19:40 to that and understand, like, hey, if I went to school here, what would what would my what might it be like? And just kind of but

Ryan:19:46 Yeah.

Chris:19:46 I didn't really know anybody. And so that was both a positive and a negative for me at the time. I I think it was a net positive. So I got into like running and biking and being like

I started reading a lot it was a good, summer. in from as in terms of internship, I don't think they got any value out of me. Like I think it was

Ryan:20:04 Hahaha

Chris:20:05 I I I feel like I showed up on time. I

Ryan:20:09 Yeah.

Chris:20:09 you know, I I did my best, but I didn't know I don't think I knew what I was doing at the time. I was just kind of, you know, and I don't think that they really expected much out of me, but yeah.

Ryan:20:14 Wow, who does right when you're 20 years old, yeah, college kid,

right? So, but cool experience, right? Yeah.

Chris:20:20 But anyways, Kalamazoo at the time it was it

was it so so there was

at the time it it it it was, I wouldn't say it was a thriving town, but it was it was okay, right?

Fast forward, I maybe like 15 years. now I have gone through life, right? And and I've lived in multiple places at this point.

and then moved to Castro Valley, where we finally bought a house. Right. And so

Ryan:20:46 Yep.

Chris:20:46 in that moment, everything was appreciating across the board anywhere in the United States. And so like this house that we had bought for, you know, six forty

was now worth $800,000. So now that's like, hey, I've got an option here. I can do a HELOC. You know, I can get a home equity

Ryan:21:00 Mmm, mmm.

Chris:21:01 line of credit on this home that I bought for $640 now worth $800. And I can do something with that money. So I was like, what can I do with that money? Well, I started looking all over the country, you know, doing, you know, what we do here on this and trying to understand like where is there going invest? And

Kalamazoo popped up because Kalamazoo was cheap. It was like I could get

Ryan:21:22 Yeah.

Chris:21:23 a duplex for $75,000. And I was like, Kalamazoo, I know Kalamazoo. I biked around Kalamazoo. I know that area. I know exactly where that neighborhood is. Yeah, so

Ryan:21:30 Yeah, I was a marginal intern in Kalamazoo.

Chris:21:35 so I was like, that's that's that's cool. and and I've a little nostalgia and I was remembering that summer, and I was just like, yeah, maybe I'll do a HELOC and buy a duplex in Kalamazoo.

And so

Ryan:21:48 Yeah.

Chris:21:49 so I did that. And initially, you know, it was it was my first time buying a, a rental property that it was actually an investment, not a primary residence. and it, you

Ryan:21:59 Yeah, yeah.

Chris:22:00 know, it and it cash flows out of the gates. I think I wanted to learn about things, so I was a little sloppy in the sense of like I I rushed into buying it before I had like a good property manager.

And then so I was

Ryan:22:15 Yeah.

Chris:22:15 having to handle some of the stuff I wouldn't want to handle normally and get in the middle of some drama, my my rent's late or whatever. And that's a whole nother topic around Kalamazoo versus Ann Arbor. but ultimately it was, you know, not a terrible experience. It was, you know, and I I like the idea of accumulating properties. So then we did another deal that which was a triplex, and then another deal which was a four-plex. So we kept investing

Ryan:22:38 Okay.

Chris:22:39 in Kalamazoo and we ultimately at at our height,

had nine doors there, right? So yeah.

Ryan:22:44 nine doors. Okay, so a triplex,

a fourplex, and then a duplex, is that right? Okay, okay.

Chris:22:48 Yeah, yeah.

Ryan:22:52 So you took advantage of the market, right? So home price, your primary resident appreciated quite a bit, like you mentioned, and then you said, you know what, I'm gonna do something with this equity. Got a heat lock and did some research and you found Kalamazoo and you bought the duplex first, is that the first

Chris:23:11 Yeah,

Ryan:23:11 Yeah, and do you mind sharing with the audience? said $75,000 was the price of a duplex in Kalamazoo at the time.

Chris:23:17 I think I ended up getting it for a hundred, because I went for

Ryan:23:20 Okay.

Chris:23:21 a slightly night. I you could but my you could find some that were seventy five, but they tended to be

Ryan:23:26 Yeah.

Chris:23:27 like more run down and worse part of town. So the one I bought was a hundred and two thousand. Yeah.

Ryan:23:31 Okay.

Okay. And again, coming from California, right, where home prices at

Chris:23:36 Yeah.

Ryan:23:36 the time, you know, close to a million dollars. Now you can, you know, go out to Kalamazoo and buy a duplex for a hundred thousand, right? Seems like a great investment, you know, can cashflow day one, possibly, right? And okay, so that.

Chris:23:50 Mm-hmm. And then I think the triplex

was 120,000. So the price per door was was lower. Yeah, yeah, exactly.

Ryan:23:54 Okay, so you get another door for 20,000 bucks, right? So, okay.

So you got nine doors. Are you managing the property yourself at, you know, kind of?

Chris:24:04 Well, initially on

the first duplex for like a month, you know, I I did because I didn't have all my systems in place. I didn't know what I didn't know, right? So I'm like, I'm gonna buy a house. And I'm like, okay, now what do I do with it? And then Yeah,

Ryan:24:12 Yeah. Now what? Now what? Yeah.

Chris:24:16 so then I, you know, then I found a property manager and I was figuring that out. And but i I think the interesting thing there was like, you know, I can get a call because initially I had to like, you know, give information of like, hey, who who do they need to contact if they have issues now? And like, so I just gave my personal

information. But

Ryan:24:34 Yeah.

Chris:24:34 that was a bad, bad decision. So I do not recommend anyone that's going into this world to be an investor of a hundred thousand dollar duplex to

Ryan:24:45 Hahaha!

Chris:24:46 give the tenant your personal information because you know yeah you see yeah.

Ryan:24:49 Yeah, where you live, Because that opens up you to lawsuits and liability, right? And that's another

kind of conversation here, right? When you buy these investment properties, right? You should throw it into an LLC, protect your assets and everything. But you're learning, right? You're figuring things out.

Chris:25:02 Well yeah, it and and and have a property

manager so they don't even know who owns the property, right? Because the problem was like I'm the owner, they know that I'm the owner. You know, they

Ryan:25:14 Yeah.

Chris:25:14 So they start trying to haggle with me on, you know, things that are already in contract, like, can I have a lower rent? I'm gonna miss a payment, like and and putting it back on me and making me feel

evil because I'm not giving them contractual discounts

Ryan:25:29 Yeah, a discount on rent or yeah.

Chris:25:31 on things that were part of the whole foundation of why this property even made sense for me to buy in the first place. Right. So it's like, well,

Ryan:25:38 Yeah.

Chris:25:38 if I let you not pay rent, guess what? I'm essentially paying your rent. So it just ended up being, initially it was a good learning experience. Like don't do this.

you because you do if you're gonna

Ryan:25:48 Yeah

Chris:25:49 especially if you're gonna be an owner of very inexpensive real estate, there I would say there's a high correlation with drama. So, you know, like on

Ryan:25:57 Yeah.

Chris:25:58 one extreme you have a slumlord, right? And and on the other extreme, you have an owner of Beverly Hills, right? Like we've talked about in episode one, you're gonna have a lot more drama on the slumlord side. And I would say

first duplex I bought in Kalamazoo was probably more like if I

Ryan:26:13 Yeah.

Chris:26:14 think about like it was I wouldn't say you know this was truly a slum but it was a hundred thousand dollar property

it's a very low rent and so the type of people that are attracted to those super

Ryan:26:24 that are gonna be attracted to that property,

Chris:26:26 low rents like they're they're scraping by right and so you know it and so like you feel kind of torn right on the

So and I'm not I don't have the slumlord mentality. and so I always was try like yeah and

Ryan:26:36 No, no, you want to take care of the property. You want to make sure

that, they got a great living situation.

Chris:26:42 Yeah.

Ryan:26:42 The rub, like you said, is they have your personal information. Now they're trying to just, you know, finagle and get deals out of you. And that puts you in a tough spot, right? It's like, hey, you

Chris:26:47 Yeah, yeah.

Ryan:26:51 want to do the right thing. You bought this as an investment. It's a decent place to live in, all things considered. But yeah, you just, got to deal with some of the headwinds of, you know, managing the property on your own. And

Chris:27:02 Yeah. Yeah. And and so

have having a property manager helped, but it was still there's still drama

And and it did appreciate a little bit. We ultimately sold out everything in Kalamazoo. and yeah, because

Ryan:27:14 Okay. Sold all nine doors, all three properties.

Chris:27:18 the because the dollar per hour wasn't really great, right? So, like in theory,

Ryan:27:21 No, yeah.

Chris:27:22 the dollar of my hours should have been okay. It ended up just being some amount of drama,

Ryan:27:28 Yeah,

Yeah. So you really, you went in as an intern, right, as an investor in Kalamazoo, and you left as a PhD, you know, student here. So, right. And I think that's maybe the yeah, trial by fire, right. And you learn a lot.

Chris:27:40 Yeah, it was fun. it's you learn by doing, right? And so you have to take some amount of risk. Yeah.

Ryan:27:46 And I think the lesson here, and I think this applies to a lot of investors is, you

You can do all of the number crunching at home on your spreadsheet, And pencil in the profits and the taxes and all those type of things, But until you actually purchase the property, get tenants in there and manage it, right? That's gonna tell you kind of the real return on investment here, right? And then what you mentioned, which is super important, is your dollar per hour, right? So you're a professional, right? You gotta get...

great career and you you want to make sure that this is penciling out not only mathematically but also looking at your time right so so how much time am I spending to manage this right and and all those things factor into this equation and again you learned a lot and I think you're a much smarter kind of investor because of that experience right

Chris:28:36 at the time another

benefit was like, okay, what's the worst what's the worst that could happen? What's the best that can happen? And what I really

Ryan:28:42 Yeah

Chris:28:42 needed at that time was to learn. And so that was a perfect market to learn because it's like the worst that can happen is I buy a hundred thousand dollar home and I sell it for seventy-five thousand dollars. I lose twenty-five thousand dollars. Not a big deal, right? What's the best that could

Ryan:28:53 Yep. Yep, yep.

Chris:28:55 happen? I can learn a lot. I'm gonna learn a lot regardless. And that's worth probably more than any amount that I can get in this in this deal. But

Ryan:29:01 That's true,

yeah. You were paying to learn, yeah.

Chris:29:02 It it it it may it may actually

cash flow. And then I've got just this what do you call it, the mail check money, you know, so it's like you know, or mailbox mail, mailbox money. There you go. I get the mailbox money, right? So that was the thing of like,

Ryan:29:09 Yeah, mailbox money, Chris. Get it right,

Chris:29:15 what's the best that can happen? I get some mailbox money. What's the worst that can happen? I lose $25,000. and some time. But it's like, yeah, it's like.

Ryan:29:21 Yeah, it's a calculated risk, right? It's a calculated bet there.

Chris:29:25 it was a great place to cut cut my teeth

encourage others, you know, to not shy away from something like that because ultimately

you can get yourself in a lot of trouble if your first deal is like a Beverly Hills deal. And then the market,

Ryan:29:37 Mm-hmm.

Chris:29:38 for whatever reason, doesn't immediately take off and do great. Like, because now you can get underwater. You can, you know, you got to think about what is your your income stream on all the various sources, whether it's your W two or other things, what are your current assets there's a reason like bankers do underwriting.

And if a banker

Ryan:29:56 Yeah.

Chris:29:57 won't lend you the money, that should be a red flag to you yourself. Because at the end of the day, the more aggressive you get, like, yeah, there's upside and there's potential, if the market does great things, but you just don't know what the market's gonna do. So

Ryan:30:11 Yeah.

No, that's a great story. I appreciate you sharing some of those details because, you just don't know until you dive in, right? And like you said, you learned a lot. And it was a great place to cut your teeth and figure this thing out. And again, you're a smart guy.

Part of this equation was, again, doing some house hacking, right? said, okay, well, let's do Airbnb here, see if we can generate some more income. And then again, you got to deal with the dynamics of having a fourplex and two doors are Airbnb, two are long-term,

Chris:30:41 Yeah, and and

Ryan:30:42 and then how does that unfold, right? So again, you're figuring things out.

Chris:30:45 Yeah. And in and I guess just a little color

on the a little color on the Airbnb thing. So we had an Airbnb at our primary residence in California and it was amazing. It was great. But we live there, right? So my

Ryan:30:54 Yeah. Yep.

Chris:30:56 dollar per hour there was amazing because I live there. Like I can see whether or not the cleaner comes in and does things. And if they don't, I can, you know, hustle over there and do it, you know, in the evening before I go to bed. So,

Ryan:31:06 Yeah.

Chris:31:07 you know, in Kalamazoo, the hypothesis was could we do that same thing from across the country, right? And the answer is.

Ryan:31:13 Yeah,

and it's harder.

Chris:31:15 No, like that was very hard.

because like a cleaner doesn't show up and then what do you do? I can't jump on a plane to go change a bed, right? that because that will happen.

Ryan:31:25 And again, like, you know, at the end of the day, you ended up selling the real estate. But if you look at Kalamazoo as a whole, right, it still might be an attractive place to invest, right? It ended up, you know, not being, you know, the place that you wanted to continue to invest. But if you look at just the city as a whole, right, you have the university there. You know, it's more than a university town in many respects, right? So you have some of the, you know, have strikers there, you have

the of the global medical kind of technology companies that are there. Pfizer is there, right? Pfizer operates a big pharmaceutical manufacturing facility.

Chris:31:54 Yeah, it's got it's got a lot of foundation. Yeah. It it that that was the other thing, is like

in my opinion, it still is underpriced. even with

Ryan:32:01 Yeah.

Chris:32:02 all the negative things I'm talking about. the median sale price, I think you said is like the low two hundred. Yeah.

Ryan:32:06 It was $224, right? So it's

below the national average. It's half the price of Ann Arbor, right? And again, you

Chris:32:14 Yeah.

Ryan:32:15 penciled in Kalamazoo initially because it was an affordable place to, get your feet wet and test

Chris:32:18 Yeah, it it's got it

Ryan:32:20 it.

Chris:32:21 I think it's underpriced and I think it will continue to go up. In fact, I think in the last year it's up twelve percent, right?

Ann Arbor is down, median sale price year on year is down seven percent, and I think

the thing that you let off is how is that even possible where university enrollment in Ann Arbor is way up, university enrollment in Kalamazoo is way down, and yet their housing market is the complete opposite. like Ann Arbor

Ryan:32:44 yeah, yeah.

Chris:32:45 down seven percent, Kalamazoo up 12%. And I think it goes back to the fundamentals you're talking about, which are like,

the jobs and the price. So you got Stryker,

Ryan:32:52 Yeah.

Chris:32:53 you got, some of these other companies that are kind of AI insulated in some ways. A lot of the companies are. And it and it's more around like life sciences. So I think, you know, West Michigan does have a a pretty good like yeah,

Ryan:33:04 Yeah, major healthcare institutions.

Chris:33:08 like medical program. I don't think Kalamazoo can drop a whole lot more than it's already dropped.

and so there's

Ryan:33:16 Mm-hmm.

Chris:33:16 just a a floor that it's already floating at. And so, if I think about the Bay Area, which is where I live, we're in this weird choppy situation where you hear every day companies laying people off because AI can, you know, can do what a developer did very easily. In fact,

Better than in most cases at this point, and much faster and much cheaper. and so that's that's hurt the Bay Area, but at the same time, all the AI companies are in the Bay Area. So there's a lot of wealth coming on the flip side of that. So the Bay Area's got a bunch of wealth coming in and a bunch of wealth going out from the same thing. In a place like Ann Arbor, I think it's mostly going out

you're gonna have a lot of people. Maybe you're a computer science major, maybe you like the university, you can work remote and do anything anywhere. You get laid off one of these tech companies, and hey, I work for a tech company right now. I almost moved to Ann Arbor because of all these things, right? I can work

Ryan:34:10 Yep.

Chris:34:11 anywhere, I can do these things, I can want a cheaper cost of living, but still a university town, still got a bunch smart people around, still got a bunch of amenities, blah, blah, blah. I was almost one of those people. And guess what? Had I done that, I'd probably be laid off right now. Because

Ryan:34:24 Yeah.

Chris:34:24 I'm not in the office.

I'm not doing certain things. And so, it so, yeah, and so like

Ryan:34:28 Yeah, out of sight, out of mind. It's easy to let Chris go, right?

Chris:34:31 going back to that dynamic you said before, like a university town is a place where a lot of people want to live, but there aren't as many, there's more people that want to live there than there are jobs. And I think that's the

Ryan:34:40 Yeah.

Chris:34:40 dynamic we're seeing between Kalamazoo and Ann Arbor. I'd say Kalamazoo's got probably a higher ratio of, wage to price of the house, and so like people with.

what modest incomes can afford to buy and and own homes there. Whereas Ann Arbor, it's the opposite where I think a lot of the money makers, are struggling to some degree.

Ryan:35:00 Yeah, yeah, that job dynamic is, I think, impacting some of these towns, right? And San Francisco might be the kind of perfect case study, right? So if you look at the median household income in Kalamazoo, it's 52,000, right? And then adults with a bachelor's degree or higher is 38%, right? So yeah, the job market might be a little bit different in the dynamics with AI kind of entering all sectors of the economy that might play a factor in that Kalamazoo area.

yeah, have you heard, I was doing some research on just Kalamazoo. Have you heard about that Kalamazoo promise? You know anything about that?

Chris:35:38 Yeah, I think that's a double edged sword from what I understand. like,

Ryan:35:41 Yeah. How do you interpret it?

Chris:35:44 you know, I think it's a good thing, philosophically.

Ryan:35:47 Yeah.

Chris:35:48 what was happening was Kalamazoo is losing population.

Ryan:35:51 Yep.

Chris:35:52 and so there's a lot of housing that you know essentially wasn't being filled. And so

Ryan:35:58 Mm-hmm.

Chris:35:59 you're gonna have to keep me honest,

So there was this anonymous donor. And I think I don't know if they've proven it was like this, you know, this billionaire family, you know, or if it was someone else. But like there's this anonymous donor that.

Ryan:36:06 Yeah, you could probably figure out who it might be.

Chris:36:11 That said, hey, if you go to Kalamazoo and graduate from high school, we'll pay for your college. and so

Ryan:36:16 exactly, exactly.

Chris:36:17 what, so then that's a great thing, right? Like, hey, so what does that do? That attracts a lot of people into Kalamazoo that otherwise might not have lived there. So they get this Kalamazoo promise and ultimately get their kids can go to university for free, if

Ryan:36:30 Yeah.

Chris:36:31 they, you know, and so that was the idea. boots on the ground,

the city, from what I remember 20 years ago to when I sold all my properties, I would say it was not the same city.

felt less safe, more chaotic. I think crime in Kalamazoo is way up, or it was,

Ryan:36:54 Okay.

Chris:36:54 now does the Kalamazoo promise play into any of that stuff? I don't really know. But I think the city itself was struggling. Some people tried some things to try to save the city. I think depending on who you ask, like it was a success success or it wasn't.

Ryan:37:09 Mm-hmm.

Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Chris:37:10 Regardless, I

the gesture was good.

I don't know what the alternative is would have been, right?

Ryan:37:14 think they went into it with good intentions, right? So you had anonymous kind of wealthy donors establish this program, basically promising to pay 100 % of college tuition for eligible graduates, right? In that Kalamazoo kind of public school area, right? So I think the parameters and guidelines were like, if you attended kindergarten through 12th grade, you're eligible for 100 % of your qualifying tuition.

be paid from this Kalamazoo Promise. If you went just from ninth to 12th grade, it was 65%. And then I think one of the limitations was you had to go to college in one of the 60 eligible universities in Michigan. But yeah, it could be, like you said, it could be a deciding factor for some of these families, imagine if you have

household with three young children, right? And you go, hey, I'm gonna move to Kalamazoo and I'm looking for a better

Chris:38:06 Yeah.

Ryan:38:06 life for my family. And, I'm gonna try and get my three kids raised and educated in this Kalamazoo public education system. you know, their college is gonna be paid for. But yeah, there's a bunch of different dynamics that kind of come into play when, you you.

you offer these incentives and some of them can be kind of net positive, some can be a net

Chris:38:24 reasons there is just

Ryan:38:27 negative. just depends on how the greater city and community is unfolding right from a variety of factors.

Chris:38:36 Yeah, that'll be an interesting thing.

At at at the end of these podcasts, we do a summary. I'll put a summary page with graphs and things like that based on what we discussed.

correlations and causation. But

Ryan:38:48 Yep.

Chris:38:48 it would be interesting just to look at Kalamazoo over the last 20 years from a lot of dimensions. understanding, like,

Ryan:38:53 Yeah, exactly.

Chris:38:54 you know, and do do I will do more analysis on Kalamazoo promise and whether I think that was a net positive or net negative. I don't know right now. I know I've heard both sides, but I think ultimately like giving people an opportunity they wouldn't have otherwise had is great. So like.

that that's net positive. The city itself just feels like it's been struggling and there's money there with big companies, so I don't understand why. it just seems like there's a disconnect.

Ryan:39:21 Yeah, yeah. again, it's a unique town, It's kind of this industrial slash college town. it's gone through its fair share of ups and downs. And again, you were there 20 years ago as an intern. You invested in the community. It has some history there, obviously, right? And you might know this, right? I know you play the banjo. You got a banjo. And you have a ukulele, right? Do you still play the ukulele? Yeah.

Chris:39:48 So f funny story, I

started playing the banjo in Kalamazoo.

Ryan:39:53 really? Okay. And did you know that in Kalamazoo? Okay, okay. yeah. Yeah.

Chris:39:55 I bought my first banjo in Kalamazoo. That's where I bought the banjo. So, the banjo I have was bought

in Kalamazoo because I was bored, right? I don't know anybody. I was like, I'm gonna go to this

Ryan:40:06 Yeah, what am I gonna do?

Chris:40:07 instrument store and and so our my company, we had this thing where we went out on like this pontoon boat with, 20 people. And

people were just having fun, boozing, whatever. and they and there was like a little

Ryan:40:22 Yeah, booze cruise.

Chris:40:24 yeah, it's like a booze crew sort of deal. And they and then there was like a a dude with a banjo and you know, and they're playing music and I was like, That's awesome. So like the next weekend I went and bought a banjo and so like a you know,

Ryan:40:36 Okay.

Chris:40:37 and so yeah, so full circle back to Kalamazoo, the banjo, yeah, that came from Kalamazoo.

Ryan:40:43 Yeah, yeah. And what I was going to mention is Kalamazoo is actually the birthplace of the Gibson guitar. know, famous guitar.

Chris:40:50 Is it? no.

Ryan:40:51 Yeah, it is. So they ultimately ended up moving to Nashville, but it originated in Kalamazoo. So I thought.

Chris:40:59 It i I will say it's

an artsy it has potential to be really, really cool. Yeah. that that was a thing I felt twenty

Ryan:41:03 Maybe this kind of revivorant...

Chris:41:07 years ago. I like, this place has so much potential.

Ryan:41:10 Yeah,

and another cool thing in kind of that Kalamazoo areas, they have that Gilmore Car Museum. I don't know if you ever toured that when you were there, but it's actually like the nation's largest car museum.

Chris:41:24 No, I didn't. I that's that that was a miss on my part. I did go to the big aviation

museum, which is really cool.

Ryan:41:31 Yep, yep.

Chris:41:32 there. And they've got all sorts of cool planes on on display.

Ryan:41:36 Yeah, and you love planes and flying and stuff.

So but yeah, they have some cool history there. And again, I think, you that whole, you know, kind of region, right, you know, even, you know, moving east into Detroit, right? I mean, it's it's gone through a lot of changes over the past, you know, call it 50 years, right. And again, there's a lot of history, a lot of people lived out there at one point. And again, there's been kind of ups and downs. But yeah, cool place, a lot of history.

And again, it's an affordable place to live. And again, I think with

Chris:42:10 Still there, I think.

Ryan:42:12 AI and just the access to information and people looking for an affordable place to live,

Chris:42:16 Destiny for me to people don't do stuff.

Ryan:42:19 right? So you may see some of these towns that have been on the wrong side of history, unfortunately, kind of begin to thrive again because the affordability play and then people begin to.

invest back into these communities. who knows Kalamazoo may continue to kind of chug along here and may surprise us. If we look in two to five years, might see Kalamazoo has done quite well for a variety of reasons.

Chris:42:50 Yeah. Yeah, I

can't really go much down below where it's at. And it's like you said, it's a cool town. yeah, maybe we'll make our predictions and we'll we'll wrap this thing up. I think we've been we're kind of at that that time. so

Ryan:43:05 Yeah, definitely.

Chris:43:06 what are you feeling after all this conversation? Are you bullish, bearish, Kalamazoo versus Ann Arbor? Or or other towns?

Ryan:43:16 Yeah,

no, and it's good to hear your kind of story and analysis. And again, looking at Ann Arbor, it's a place that you've actually purchased a home. You're thinking about moving your family there, and it checks a handful of boxes. And I think overall, that would probably be a better place to buy and live. And Kalamazoo may be a better place to invest.

right, long term. I'm still kind of unpacking everything in Kalamazoo. And I think I would most likely probably invest in Kalamazoo and live in Ann Arbor

So I think at today's prices, if I'm leaning into Kalamazoo, I want to positively cash flow, get some decent tenants in a solid neighborhood and some appreciation upside. We've seen Kalamazoo kind of appreciate.

Chris:44:08 yeah I think that's probably a good one if you're looking you know from a left brain analytical you're looking at the numbers I think Kalamazoo is going to outperform Ann Arbor

It's a cool town. It's got a cool history, a lot of, a lot of soul. You know, I'd say that city feels like you just feel the soul when you're walking through there. And it's that's what really drew me.

initially to it and I'm that's why I'm rooting for Kalamazoo.

Ryan:44:32 Yep.

Chris:44:36 I've had my battle scars of of owning property there. and and you know, and maybe that's kind of some the the fun that people

Ryan:44:38 Yeah.

Chris:44:43 like. If you if you want an experience, you want to cut your teeth, it's a great place. And and you can make some good returns. the the challenge is you're making good returns on low, low amounts of money. So hey, I made, you know, 50k on you

Ryan:44:54 Yeah.

Chris:44:55 know, and then I've spent, you know, a ton of time on it. But you know, for me at this point in this stage of life, like I'm I'm

I don't want to cut my teeth anymore. I want to actually make money in like in my

Ryan:45:06 Yeah.

Chris:45:07 dollar per hour. And so like, I'm probably still sitting on the sidelines and both, that's the macro thing, like, right? I don't know when things start turning green again as as a nation.

Ryan:45:16 Mm-hmm, mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

Chris:45:17 like I'm trying to build the gunpowder so that I can make that big shot when things turn around. And so right now, Cash is king.

I'm sitting on the sidelines in both markets. I'm holding what I have in Ann Arbor. I'm not selling. I've got a great interest rate on that house. I'm and it's in a safe and it's cash flowing. And it's not appreciating. Last year went from being worth, you know, X to being like worth 96% of X or whatever the depreciation

Ryan:45:41 Yeah.

Chris:45:41 was over the past year. But like, I'm not selling Ann Arbor, but I'm not buying it right now. there's too much inventory.

Ryan:45:48 mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

Chris:45:50 too many price cuts, interest rates still still too high. And AI is making making things complicated. now my prediction will be this a lot of this stuff will be sorted out and figured out. It's a great place to live. I don't know if it's two years or four years. I'm gonna say it's I'm gonna say it's

Three years from now will be a great time to be buying Ann Arbor. Between now and three years, I'm not buying it. So I

Ryan:46:16 Okay.

Chris:46:17 think Kalamazoo will continue to have tailwinds because it's it's already at the floor. I don't think it can go down much more than it already has.

Ryan:46:23 Yeah, yeah.

Chris:46:25 And so it's a it's a safer investment, even today. And so I would, I don't know, I'm still not buying it, but if I have stuff, I'm probably holding it.

So yeah, I think I'm I'm with you on Kalamazoo. Kalamazoo's probably the better investment right now.

Ryan:46:40 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Yeah, sit on the sidelines, wait, let the kind of interest rate and macroeconomics unfold and yeah, maybe sit on the sidelines, like you said, and maybe snipe something, when the time's right.

yeah. And again, real estate, generally speaking, I mean, it's less liquid, right. I mean, it's not like, you know, buying a stock where you can buy today and sell tomorrow.

When you're buying real estate, I think the five years the minimum window to think about it.

Chris:47:05 Agree.

Ryan:47:06 And 10 is probably the optimal, 10 plus. So yeah, I remain bullish. yeah, the short term predictions are interesting. But yeah, I think both will do well long term.

yeah, good to see you, brother.

Chris:47:19 Yep, me too. Speaking

of my seventh grade daughter. Yeah. All right.

Ryan:47:23 There she is, hey, hey. Okay.

Chris:47:27 well, let's let's end it here. I gotta figure out what's going on on the home front and then get

Ryan:47:31 Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.

Chris:47:35 get back to work here. It's almost it's almost starting time for my day job. So but yeah, great,

Ryan:47:39 Yeah, me too.

Chris:47:40 great third episode. we'll keep it going and we'll keep learning and and optimizing. So

Ryan:47:47 Okay, you're awesome brother. Yep.

Chris:47:47 Have a good weekend. We'll we'll chat,

I'm sure, just off and on and we'll do this again next week.

Ryan:47:53 Yeah, episode four coming next week. So, right on. Take care, brother. I'll see you soon. Bye.

Chris:47:55 All right. Yeah. All right. Later, man. All right, bye.

A recorded conversation. The hosts' views and predictions are their own opinions, not HousingGauge scores, forecasts or financial advice.