Ann Arbor HousingGauge — October 26, 2026 | RED 42
Episode 17 · October 27, 2026 · Leah and Marcus (AI hosts)
Audio for this archived episode is not available — the transcript is below.
Key takeaways
- Mortgage rates up 0.74 points in three months. The 30-year fixed rate averages 7.32%, versus 6.58% three months ago.
- Local employment down 6.4% year over year. Unemployment stands at 3.4%.
- Inventory up 29.7% year over year. 358 homes are listed for sale, equal to 3.7 months of supply.
Transcript
Leah: Prices in Ann Arbor are down 6.9% from a year ago, the steepest drop of the 11 markets we track. We'll get into why that matters.
Hi, and welcome to the Ann Arbor HousingGauge. It's the week of October 26, 2026, and I'm Leah.
Marcus: I'm Marcus. Good to be here.
Leah: Before we start: we're both AI voices, reading from HousingGauge's data. Every figure is sourced at housinggauge.com.
Quick scoreboard before we dig in.
Marcus: Ann Arbor scores 42 out of 100 this week, which is RED. Same as last week. Three months ago it was 51, and a year ago, 57.
Leah: Heading the wrong direction, then.
Prices in Ann Arbor are down 6.9% from a year ago. That sounds like nothing's happening.
Marcus: On the sticker, maybe. But consumer prices are up 3.7%, so in real terms the typical home is 10.3% cheaper than it was a year ago.
Leah: Prices falling without falling.
Marcus: That's often how housing corrects. Not with a crash, but with a long stall where inflation does the work. Sellers don't feel like they're cutting anything, so it rarely makes headlines.
Leah: Put Ann Arbor next to the other markets we cover. What jumps out?
Marcus: Two things. The first is supply. Listings in Ann Arbor are up 29.7% from a year ago, the fastest growth of the 11 markets we track. The typical market on our list is up 9.5%. When supply builds faster than anywhere else, that's where leverage shifts to buyers first.
Leah: What's the other one?
Marcus: How fast homes sell. Homes in Ann Arbor sell for 98.8% of their list price, near the top of the 11 markets we track. For comparison, the median market we track is at 97.9%. Buyers here pay closer to asking than almost anywhere we track.
Leah: That's a useful way to see it. Same score range, very different market.
Let's talk about contracts. Pending sales, homes going under contract, are down 15.7% from a year ago, while closed sales are down 1.6%. Why do you watch contracts more closely than sales?
Marcus: Because a closed sale is history and a pending sale is a promise. Closings trail contracts by a month or two, so pending sales are the closest thing a market has to a look ahead. Right now that look ahead shows fewer households willing to commit.
Leah: Fewer people want to move?
Marcus: Not necessarily. Often it's the same people, waiting: for a lower rate, a better listing, or more certainty about their own jobs. Demand that waits doesn't disappear. But it doesn't pay a seller's mortgage, either.
Leah: So if contracts pick back up, that's the first sign something's turning.
Marcus: That's the first place you'd see it. Prices are usually the last.
Leah: How much does the University of Michigan shape Ann Arbor's housing market?
Marcus: A lot. Leases, faculty moves and graduate students all turn over on an academic cycle, so the rental market keeps its own calendar. Typical rent here is $2,026 a month, and a big share of demand comes from people whose plans are set by the school year, not by mortgage rates.
Leah: So the rent side of Ann Arbor runs on semesters.
Let's do the investor question. Somebody's sitting on cash. A Ann Arbor house, or leave it in savings?
Marcus: Not our call to make for anyone. It depends on taxes, timing and the rest of their money. Here's how the numbers line up, though. Rent on a typical home here comes to 5.3% of the price per year, before any costs. Cash-like savings, which track the Fed's rate, pay around 3.88%.
Leah: So the rental out-earns the savings account, at least before costs.
Marcus: Before costs. Run the real expenses and that edge narrows fast, and the house carries price risk that savings don't.
Leah: What about using a mortgage?
Marcus: Borrowing at 7.32% to own something whose rent yields 5.3% means the rent doesn't cover the interest, so you're paying every month for the chance of appreciation. Leverage magnifies whatever prices do next, in both directions. As always, that's arithmetic, not advice. Your taxes, timeline and other holdings change the answer, so run it past a professional.
Leah: What would it take to move Ann Arbor out of RED?
Marcus: Not much. The decline in pending sales narrowing to less than 4.0% would probably do it on its own, and so would mortgage rates falling below 6.50%.
Leah: That's the Ann Arbor HousingGauge for the week of October 26, 2026.
Marcus: A reminder that the HousingGauge score describes market conditions. It isn't a recommendation to buy or sell, and it isn't individualized financial advice. Charts and sources are at housinggauge.com.
Leah: We'll be back next week. Thanks for listening.
