Skip to content
HousingGauge

Fort Myers–Cape Coral: ZIP-code divergence

How differently Fort Myers–Cape Coral's ZIP codes have appreciated, how that spread has changed since 2000, and which ZIP codes lead and lag the region. Data through September 30, 2026.

Divergence, 5-yr growth

1.6 pp

0.0 pp vs a year ago · equal-weighted 1.7 pp

Divergence index

50

0–100 among all regions' readings to date

ZIP growth range, 5-yr

−0.6% to +3.4%

10th to 90th percentile · region +1.2% a year

Coverage

29 of 31 ZIPs

complete history since 2000 · 99% declined in the last year

Divergence over time

Standard deviation of 5-year annualized ZIP appreciation, percentage points

Housing-weighted · 1.64 pp now Equal-weighted · 1.75 pp now
View as table
DateHousing-weighted, ppEqual-weighted, pp
Dec 20052.332.53
Dec 20061.852.12
Dec 20071.441.68
Dec 20081.621.71
Dec 20092.773.10
Dec 20103.503.89
Dec 20113.423.81
Dec 20123.183.53
Dec 20132.292.23
Dec 20142.262.56
Dec 20153.003.50
Dec 20163.644.05
Dec 20173.403.72
Dec 20182.883.13
Dec 20192.762.98
Dec 20202.362.49
Dec 20211.781.76
Dec 20221.191.24
Dec 20231.631.85
Dec 20241.531.79
Dec 20251.701.89
Sep 20261.641.75
33920 Alva: $381K · 5-yr +2.3% a year (+1.1 pp vs region)33922 Bokeelia: $357K · 5-yr +0.8% a year (−0.4 pp vs region)33931 Fort Myers Beach: $483K · 5-yr −2.0% a year (−3.2 pp vs region)33956 Saint James City: $427K · 5-yr +0.9% a year (−0.3 pp vs region)33957 Sanibel: $799K · 5-yr −3.2% a year (−4.4 pp vs region)33965: fewer than 400 housing units33901 Fort Myers: $256K · 5-yr +1.1% a year (−0.1 pp vs region)33903 North Fort Myers: $224K · 5-yr −0.4% a year (−1.7 pp vs region)33904 Cape Coral: $336K · 5-yr −0.6% a year (−1.8 pp vs region)33905 Fort Myers: $279K · 5-yr +2.0% a year (+0.8 pp vs region)33907 Fort Myers: $198K · 5-yr +0.2% a year (−1.0 pp vs region)33908 Fort Myers: $319K · 5-yr −0.4% a year (−1.6 pp vs region)33909 Cape Coral: $292K · 5-yr +1.4% a year (+0.2 pp vs region)33912 Fort Myers: $376K · 5-yr +2.3% a year (+1.1 pp vs region)33913 Fort Myers: $440K · 5-yr +2.1% a year (+0.9 pp vs region)33914 Cape Coral: $421K · 5-yr +0.1% a year (−1.1 pp vs region)33916 Fort Myers: $210K · 5-yr +2.5% a year (+1.3 pp vs region)33917 North Fort Myers: $289K · 5-yr +1.3% a year (+0.1 pp vs region)33919 Fort Myers: $243K · 5-yr +0.1% a year (−1.1 pp vs region)33928 Estero: $473K · 5-yr +3.5% a year (+2.3 pp vs region)33966 Fort Myers: $333K · 5-yr +2.4% a year (+1.2 pp vs region)33967 Fort Myers: $351K · 5-yr +2.5% a year (+1.3 pp vs region)33971 Lehigh Acres: $283K · 5-yr +3.2% a year (+2.0 pp vs region)33972 Lehigh Acres: $310K · 5-yr +4.3% a year (+3.0 pp vs region)33973 Lehigh Acres: $280K · 5-yr +2.9% a year (+1.7 pp vs region)33974 Lehigh Acres: $285K · 5-yr +4.4% a year (+3.2 pp vs region)33976 Lehigh Acres: $282K · 5-yr +3.0% a year (+1.7 pp vs region)33990 Cape Coral: $321K · 5-yr +0.4% a year (−0.9 pp vs region)33991 Cape Coral: $358K · 5-yr +0.2% a year (−1.0 pp vs region)33993 Cape Coral: $325K · 5-yr +1.4% a year (+0.1 pp vs region)34134 Bonita Springs: $629K · 5-yr +1.7% a year (+0.5 pp vs region)34135 Bonita Springs: $457K · 5-yr +3.4% a year (+2.1 pp vs region)
below −2%−2% to 0%0% to +2%+2% to +4%+4% to +6%+6% to +8%+8% or moreinsufficient data

Dots are ZIP code centers. Hover for values; select a dot for the ZIP report.

Leading the region, last 5 years
ZIPTypical value5-yr, %/yrvs region, pp
33974Lehigh Acres$285K+4.4%+3.2
33972Lehigh Acres$310K+4.3%+3.0
33928Estero$473K+3.5%+2.3
34135Bonita Springs$457K+3.4%+2.1
33971Lehigh Acres$283K+3.2%+2.0
33976Lehigh Acres$282K+3.0%+1.7
33973Lehigh Acres$280K+2.9%+1.7
33967Fort Myers$351K+2.5%+1.3
33916Fort Myers$210K+2.5%+1.3
33966Fort Myers$333K+2.4%+1.2
Lagging the region, last 5 years
ZIPTypical value5-yr, %/yrvs region, pp
33957Sanibel$799K−3.2%−4.4
33931Fort Myers Beach$483K−2.0%−3.2
33904Cape Coral$336K−0.6%−1.8
33903North Fort Myers$224K−0.4%−1.7
33908Fort Myers$319K−0.4%−1.6
33914Cape Coral$421K+0.1%−1.1
33919Fort Myers$243K+0.1%−1.1
33907Fort Myers$198K+0.2%−1.0
33991Cape Coral$358K+0.2%−1.0
33990Cape Coral$321K+0.4%−0.9

Leading or lagging describes past appreciation only. It is not a prediction of what comes next.

Turning points

Where long divergence is reversing. Each ZIP code's relative price (its value divided by a Fort Myers–Cape Coral index) shows whether it has been gaining or losing ground. A ZIP code turns up when it trailed the region for 5 years, was still losing ground a year ago, and has kept pace or better since. Divergence across Fort Myers–Cape Coral ZIP codes peaked at 3.8 points in 2017 and has settled to 1.6 points: the ZIPs are moving more alike after a period of wide divergence.

Fort Myers–Cape Coral values −3.3% over 12 months · U.S. (ZIP codes HousingGauge tracks) +1.1%. Data through Sep 2026.

Turning up after a long lag 2Catching up 0Lag narrowing 2Still falling behind 0Leader turning down 5Leader losing ground 1Leading 1
-4-20+2-4-20+2+4Lagged, now gainingLagged, still losing groundLed, still gainingLed, now losing ground33908 Fort Myers · Lag narrowing Pent-up gap −2.0 pp a year Last 12 months −1.3 pp (a year earlier −3.3 pp)33903 North Fort Myers · Lag narrowing Pent-up gap −1.6 pp a year Last 12 months −1.2 pp (a year earlier −2.6 pp)33919 Fort Myers · Near the region Pent-up gap −0.9 pp a year Last 12 months −3.5 pp (a year earlier −4.4 pp)33907 Fort Myers · Near the region Pent-up gap −0.7 pp a year Last 12 months −4.7 pp (a year earlier −5.0 pp)33956 Saint James City · Near the region Pent-up gap −0.5 pp a year Last 12 months +5.9 pp (a year earlier +0.3 pp)33904 Cape Coral · Near the region Pent-up gap −0.5 pp a year Last 12 months +0.7 pp (a year earlier −1.4 pp)33922 Bokeelia · Near the region Pent-up gap −0.3 pp a year Last 12 months +0.7 pp (a year earlier −1.9 pp)33990 Cape Coral · Near the region Pent-up gap −0.3 pp a year Last 12 months +0.8 pp (a year earlier +0.4 pp)33991 Cape Coral · Near the region Pent-up gap −0.2 pp a year Last 12 months +1.4 pp (a year earlier +1.5 pp)33917 North Fort Myers · Near the region Pent-up gap −0.2 pp a year Last 12 months +1.4 pp (a year earlier +1.4 pp)34134 Bonita Springs · Near the region Pent-up gap −0.1 pp a year Last 12 months +1.6 pp (a year earlier +0.2 pp)33914 Cape Coral · Near the region Pent-up gap −0.1 pp a year Last 12 months +2.2 pp (a year earlier −0.3 pp)33901 Fort Myers · Near the region Pent-up gap 0.0 pp a year Last 12 months −1.0 pp (a year earlier −1.9 pp)33966 Fort Myers · Near the region Pent-up gap +0.2 pp a year Last 12 months +1.1 pp (a year earlier +1.0 pp)33913 Fort Myers · Near the region Pent-up gap +0.6 pp a year Last 12 months +1.3 pp (a year earlier +1.2 pp)33912 Fort Myers · Near the region Pent-up gap +0.6 pp a year Last 12 months +1.2 pp (a year earlier +0.3 pp)33905 Fort Myers · Near the region Pent-up gap +0.6 pp a year Last 12 months −0.7 pp (a year earlier +1.3 pp)33967 Fort Myers · Near the region Pent-up gap +0.6 pp a year Last 12 months −0.5 pp (a year earlier +3.3 pp)33909 Cape Coral · Near the region Pent-up gap +0.7 pp a year Last 12 months −0.5 pp (a year earlier +2.1 pp)33993 Cape Coral · Near the region Pent-up gap +1.2 pp a year Last 12 months −0.5 pp (a year earlier +1.8 pp)33920 Alva · Near the region Pent-up gap +1.3 pp a year Last 12 months +0.1 pp (a year earlier +3.4 pp)33928 Estero · Near the region Pent-up gap +1.3 pp a year Last 12 months +1.0 pp (a year earlier +3.0 pp)34135 Bonita Springs · Leading Pent-up gap +1.5 pp a year Last 12 months +1.1 pp (a year earlier +1.9 pp)33916 Fort Myers · Leader losing ground Pent-up gap +1.7 pp a year Last 12 months −2.7 pp (a year earlier −0.1 pp)33931 Fort Myers Beach · Turning up after a long lag Pent-up gap −3.9 pp a year Last 12 months +3.4 pp (a year earlier −3.4 pp)33957 Sanibel · Turning up after a long lag Pent-up gap −5.0 pp a year Last 12 months +3.3 pp (a year earlier −2.2 pp)33973 Lehigh Acres · Leader turning down Pent-up gap +1.4 pp a year Last 12 months −5.3 pp (a year earlier +5.0 pp)33971 Lehigh Acres · Leader turning down Pent-up gap +2.3 pp a year Last 12 months −1.6 pp (a year earlier +2.8 pp)33976 Lehigh Acres · Leader turning down Pent-up gap +2.4 pp a year Last 12 months −3.0 pp (a year earlier +2.0 pp)33972 Lehigh Acres · Leader turning down Pent-up gap +3.1 pp a year Last 12 months −0.6 pp (a year earlier +4.1 pp)33974 Lehigh Acres · Leader turning down Pent-up gap +3.3 pp a year Last 12 months −1.9 pp (a year earlier +2.3 pp)Pent-up gap: relative growth over the 5 years to a year ago, points a year (left = lagged)
Turning up after a long lag Leader turning down Other ZIP codesVertical axis: last 12 months vs the region, points. Each line runs from a year ago (end without a dot) to now (dot).
Turning up after a long lag: 2 ZIP codes, strongest turns first
ZIP codePent-up gapLast 12 mo12 mo beforeSince lowTurned upBusinesses vs regionIncomes vs regionTypical value
33931 · Fort Myers Beach−18.2%+3.4 pp−3.4 pp+3.4%May 2026−12.2 pp+8.0 pp$483K
33957 · Sanibel−22.7%+3.3 pp−2.2 pp+3.4%Jun 2026−11.2 pp−3.4 pp$799K
Lag narrowing (still trailing, by less than a year ago): the ten strongest
ZIP codePent-up gapLast 12 mo12 mo beforeSince lowTurned upBusinesses vs regionIncomes vs regionTypical value
33908 · Fort Myers−9.4%−1.3 pp−3.3 pp0.0%—−3.2 pp+2.8 pp$319K
33903 · North Fort Myers−7.8%−1.2 pp−2.6 pp0.0%—−3.8 pp−0.7 pp$224K

Businesses and incomes vs region: growth a year minus the region's over the latest three published years (Census business counts, IRS income per tax return); ✓ = turning up with business establishments growing faster than the region. A description of the last six years, not a forecast: HousingGauge's research has not validated turning points as a signal of future outperformance. Research · Method

Earlier periods with similar divergence

Years when Fort Myers–Cape Coral's 5-year divergence was close to today's 1.6 pp, and where it stood later.

ThenDivergence3 years later5 years later
December 31, 20061.9 pp2.8 pp3.4 pp
March 31, 20071.8 pp3.1 pp3.4 pp
December 31, 20081.6 pp3.4 pp2.3 pp
December 31, 20211.8 pp1.5 ppnot yet observed
March 31, 20221.7 pp1.6 ppnot yet observed
June 30, 20231.4 pp1.7 ppnot yet observed

A falling number means ZIP growth rates became more similar. That is not the same as cheaper ZIP codes catching up. What the research found across all regions

Historical explorer

Pick a year to see which ZIP codes were leading and lagging then, and what actually happened over the next one, three or five years.

Open the Fort Myers–Cape Coral explorer

All 31 ZIP codes

ZIPTypical valuevs region median1-yr5-yr10-yr5-yr vs region
33974 Lehigh Acres$285K88%−5.1%+4.4%+7.3%+3.2 pp
33972 Lehigh Acres$310K95%−3.8%+4.3%+7.3%+3.0 pp
33928 Estero$473K145%−2.4%+3.5%+3.8%+2.3 pp
34135 Bonita Springs$457K140%−2.2%+3.4%+4.4%+2.1 pp
33971 Lehigh Acres$283K87%−4.9%+3.2%+6.8%+2.0 pp
33976 Lehigh Acres$282K87%−6.2%+3.0%+7.0%+1.7 pp
33973 Lehigh Acres$280K86%−8.4%+2.9%+6.3%+1.7 pp
33967 Fort Myers$351K108%−3.8%+2.5%+4.9%+1.3 pp
33916 Fort Myers$210K65%−5.8%+2.5%+6.7%+1.3 pp
33966 Fort Myers$333K103%−2.3%+2.4%+3.8%+1.2 pp
33912 Fort Myers$376K116%−2.1%+2.3%+3.7%+1.1 pp
33920 Alva$381K117%−3.1%+2.3%+5.3%+1.1 pp
33913 Fort Myers$440K135%−2.0%+2.1%+3.9%+0.9 pp
33905 Fort Myers$279K86%−4.0%+2.0%+5.8%+0.8 pp
34134 Bonita Springs$629K194%−1.7%+1.7%+3.6%+0.5 pp
33909 Cape Coral$292K90%−3.8%+1.4%+5.2%+0.2 pp
33993 Cape Coral$325K100%−3.8%+1.4%+5.1%+0.1 pp
33917 North Fort Myers$289K89%−1.9%+1.3%+4.5%+0.1 pp
33901 Fort Myers$256K79%−4.2%+1.1%+5.2%−0.1 pp
33956 Saint James City$427K131%+2.4%+0.9%+4.7%−0.3 pp
33922 Bokeelia$357K110%−2.6%+0.8%+4.7%−0.4 pp
33990 Cape Coral$321K99%−2.5%+0.4%+4.7%−0.9 pp
33991 Cape Coral$358K110%−1.9%+0.2%+4.6%−1.0 pp
33907 Fort Myers$198K61%−7.8%+0.2%+3.3%−1.0 pp
33919 Fort Myers$243K75%−6.7%+0.1%+3.1%−1.1 pp
33914 Cape Coral$421K129%−1.2%+0.1%+4.6%−1.1 pp
33908 Fort Myers$319K98%−4.5%−0.4%+2.3%−1.6 pp
33903 North Fort Myers$224K69%−4.5%−0.4%+4.1%−1.7 pp
33904 Cape Coral$336K103%−2.6%−0.6%+4.3%−1.8 pp
33931 Fort Myers Beach$483K149%0.0%−2.0%+2.4%−3.2 pp
33957 Sanibel$799K246%−0.1%−3.2%+1.5%−4.4 pp

Growth is annualized; "vs region" subtracts the region's housing-weighted average over the same years. ZIP codes with fewer than 1,000 residents or 400 homes, mostly outside the metro, or without current Zillow data are shown on the map as insufficient data. Home values: Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI). Rents: Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI). Methodology