Skip to content
HousingGauge

53558 · McFarland, WI

Dane County, in the Madison metro region. A ZIP-code report built from Zillow, FHFA and Census data. ZIP codes don't carry a HousingGauge score; the region does: 49 YELLOW

Typical home value

$491K

Zillow ZHVI, September 30, 2026

Growth, last 5 years

+4.4% a year

−0.5 pp vs the region

Growth, last 10 years

+5.5% a year

−0.5 pp vs the region

Typical rent

$1,715

Zillow ZORI not available for this ZIP

Typical home value since 2000

Divergence from the Madison metro: is it turning?

Near the region

Over the 5 years to Sep 2025, 53558 trailed the Madison metro by 0.5 points a year (−2% in all). Over the last 12 months it ran −0.3 points against the region, after −0.5 points the year before. Neither far behind nor far ahead of its region over the pent-up window.

Pent-up gap

−2.3%

vs the region, 5 years to Sep 2025; 10 years: −5%

Last 12 months

−0.3 pp

vs the region, to Sep 2026

The 12 months before

−0.5 pp

vs the region

Since its 10-year low

+0.2%

relative to the region; low in Jun 2026

Madison metro values +2.5% over 12 months · U.S. (ZIP codes HousingGauge tracks) +1.1%. Divergence across Madison metro ZIP codes is widening: 1.8 points, up from 1.7 a year earlier.

Relative price: this ZIP's typical value divided by the Madison metro index (2016 = 100). Falling = losing ground.

12-month change in relative price, percentage points

Gaining on the region Losing ground Lowest point in 10 years
View as table
MonthRelative price (2016 = 100)12-month change, pp
Dec 201699.7-1.0
Dec 201799.3-0.5
Dec 201899.1-0.1
Dec 201998.6-0.5
Dec 202097.9-0.7
Dec 202198.3+0.3
Dec 202298.4+0.1
Dec 202397.0-1.4
Dec 202496.3-0.7
Dec 202596.1-0.2
Sep 202695.4-0.3

How this works: turning-point method · Turning points in Madison metro

New businesses and incomes

Is the neighborhood itself changing? Growth over the latest three published years, against the Madison metro. Business counts lead by about two years and tax data by about three, so these lag home values.

MeasureThis ZIPGrowth a yearMadison metroYears
Business establishments261−1.7%slower+1.0%2020–2023
Restaurants, cafés and bars17+2.0%faster+1.7%2020–2023
Income per tax return$126,613+9.8%faster+5.9%2020–2023
Tax returns with income over $100,00041%+6.6 pts33% (+6.9 pts)2020–2023
Adults with a bachelor's degree50%+3.9 pts—2010–14 to 2020–2024
Residents aged 25–3410%+0.5 pts—2010–14 to 2020–2024

Growth columns: % a year for counts and income; percentage-point change for shares (education and age: change since 2010–14). Income is nominal adjusted gross income per IRS return, not household income; comparing with the region removes inflation common to both.

Business establishments

1994 = 100 · Census ZIP Codes Business Patterns

This ZIP · 151 Madison metro · 131

Income per tax return

2011 = 100 · IRS ZIP statistics (nominal)

This ZIP · 181 Madison metro · 166

Sources: U.S. Census Bureau ZIP Codes Business Patterns; IRS Statistics of Income ZIP code data; American Community Survey 5-year estimates.

Compared with the Madison metro

WindowThis ZIPRegionDifferenceRank
1 yr+2.2%+2.6%−0.4 ppfaster than 15%
3 yr+2.8%+3.4%−0.6 ppfaster than 5%
5 yr+4.4%+4.9%−0.5 ppfaster than 7%
10 yr+5.5%+6.0%−0.5 ppfaster than 7%

Price relative to the region's median ZIP code: 113% today, 117% five years ago, 119% ten years ago. Its price gap with the region has moved down.

Affordability and neighborhood change

Median household income
$108K
+53% since 2010–14 (nominal)
Home value / income
4.6×
Median rent burden
29% of income
Price-to-rent
23.9× annual rent
gross yield 4.2%
Owner-occupied
77%
Bachelor's degree or higher
50%
adults 25+
Population
13,164
+19% since 2010–14
Housing units
5,496
+18% since 2010–14

Rising home values also mean rising costs for people who live here. Census ACS 5-year estimates (ACS 5-year 2020–2024 vs ACS 5-year 2010–2014); ZIP Code Tabulation Areas.

Historical position

  • Last five years: in the slowest quarter of Madison metro ZIP codes.
  • Price: above the region's median ZIP code.
  • Within 5 miles of a top-quarter-priced ZIP code: no.

These are descriptions of the past, not predictions. HousingGauge's research has not validated them as signals of future outperformance. Research report

Nearby ZIP codes

ZIPDistanceTypical value5-yr growthvs region
53716 Madison5.1 mi$414K+6.2%+1.2 pp
53527 Cottage Grove5.6 mi$478K+5.4%+0.5 pp
53589 Stoughton5.7 mi$433K+5.8%+0.9 pp
53713 Madison6.6 mi$359K+5.4%+0.5 pp
53711 Madison6.8 mi$506K+5.7%+0.8 pp
53718 Madison6.9 mi$434K+5.0%+0.1 pp
53715 Madison7.0 mi$502K+5.4%+0.5 pp
53575 Oregon7.2 mi$500K+5.6%+0.7 pp

Home values: Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI, middle tier, smoothed) through September 30, 2026. Rents: Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI). Long-run index: FHFA ZIP5 house price index (1976–2025). Demographics: U.S. Census Bureau ACS. ZIP Code Tabulation Areas approximate postal ZIP codes. This page describes market data; it is not investment, appraisal or lending advice, and HousingGauge does not use race, ethnicity or other protected characteristics in any analysis. Methodology