Skip to content
HousingGauge

Special episode

HousingGauge National: Ten years, ten markets, and the rest of the world

October 3, 2026 · 22:31 · Maya and Ben (AI hosts)

0:0022:31

A long-form conversation about American housing. How the last decade played out in the 10 markets we track, why no market is GREEN today, what's happening on the ground from Nashville to Danville, how other countries do housing differently, and a thought experiment: how an economist might think about putting a billion dollars to work.

In this episode

  • The best and worst moments for buyersBy our score, every market we track looked best for buyers in early 2020 and worst in the second half of 2023, when the 30-year rate peaked at 7.79%.
  • Corrections without crashesAfter inflation, prices are down from a year ago in Nashville (down 3.7%), Fort Worth (down 5.2%) and Dallas (down 3.3%), even where sticker prices barely moved.
  • The American mortgage is unusualFew countries offer a 30-year fixed rate you can refinance freely. It protected owners from the rate shock, and it's a big reason so few of them are selling.
  • Lending beats landlording, on paperWith mortgages at 7.03%, the rate on a home loan is higher than the gross rental yield in every market we track; the highest yield is Indianapolis at 6.4%.

Transcript

Maya: Ten years ago, a typical home in Indianapolis sold for $128,000. Today it's $260,000. And here's the twist: by our score, Indianapolis was a better market for buyers back then. It scored 73, which was GREEN. Today it's 49, YELLOW.

Ben: Same city, roughly double the price, and a worse deal. That sentence is basically the last decade of American housing.

Maya: This is HousingGauge National, our long-form conversation about housing across the country. I'm Maya.

Ben: And I'm Ben.

Maya: As always, Ben and I are AI voices, and every number you'll hear comes from HousingGauge's data. Our home price, inventory and sales figures come from Redfin's Data Center, rents from Zillow's Observed Rent Index, jobs from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, incomes from the Census Bureau, and rates and inflation from the Federal Reserve's data. Today we're zooming out. We'll look at a decade in the 10 markets we track, what we're seeing on the ground right now, how other countries do housing very differently, and then a thought experiment I've wanted to try for a while.

Ben: The billion dollars.

Maya: The billion dollars. But we'll earn it first. Start with the scoreboard. Where does the country stand this week?

Ben: Of the 10 markets we track, 6 are YELLOW and 4 are RED. Not one is GREEN.

Maya: When was the last time anything was GREEN?

Ben: That's the first fun fact of the day. When we ran the full ten years of history through the same scoring model, every single market had its best reading in the first months of 2020. Tampa peaked at 80 in April 2020. Dallas hit 78 in January 2020. Even Danville, which is expensive in any decade, got to 65.

Maya: Right before the pandemic.

Ben: Right before the pandemic, and in the first weeks of it. Mortgage rates were falling, the Fed was cutting, prices hadn't run yet, and supply was still normal. If you define a good market for buyers as cheap money plus room to negotiate, that was the moment.

Maya: And the worst?

Ben: Also remarkably synchronized: the second half of 2023. Phoenix bottomed at 27 in August 2023. Dallas at 28. Danville fell all the way to 18 in July 2023. That was when the 30-year mortgage rate peaked, at 7.79% in October 2023.

Maya: So the best and the worst moments were national, not local.

Ben: The timing was national. The depth was local. And that's the theme I'd put over this whole conversation: rates set the tide, but every market has its own shoreline.

Maya: Let's do the tide, then. Walk me through the rate story.

Ben: Ten years ago, the average 30-year fixed rate was 3.42%. It drifted, and then the pandemic pushed it to the lowest level in our data, 2.65%, in January 2021. The Fed's own rate was 0.09%, essentially zero. Then inflation arrived. Consumer prices were rising 9.0% a year at the peak, in July 2022, and the Fed raised its rate to 5.33%. Mortgage rates followed, all the way to 7.79%. Today the 30-year rate is 7.03%, the fed funds rate is 3.88%, and inflation is running at 3.4%.

Maya: In plain terms, what did that do to buyers?

Ben: The cleanest way to see it is what we call payment-to-income: principal and interest on a typical home as a share of the median household's income. In Fort Worth, five years ago, that was 19.9%. Today it's 26.8%. In Indianapolis it went from 17.8% to 25.1%. Those are still the affordable markets. In Danville it's 50.1%, and in South Lake Tahoe 49.7%.

Maya: Half of income.

Ben: Before taxes, insurance or a single repair. That's the price of time going up. A mortgage is how you buy thirty years of time, and in a few short years that time got a lot more expensive.

Maya: I want to stay on the pandemic years for a minute, because I think people forget how strange they were.

Ben: Our data makes it vivid. In December 2021, Danville had 0.2 months of supply. At the sales pace of the time, every listing in town would have been gone in about a week. Five years ago, a typical Indianapolis home went under contract in 5 days. In Oklahoma City, 6 days.

Maya: And now?

Ben: Indianapolis is at 24 days. Oklahoma City, 36 days. Nashville is at 64 days, the longest of any market we track.

Maya: What about rents during the boom?

Ben: Rents were the part people felt most directly. Five years ago, Tampa rents were up 22.3% from a year earlier. Phoenix, up 21.1%. Those are extraordinary numbers for something people pay every month. Today, Tampa rents are down 0.8% from a year ago and Phoenix rents are up 0.6%.

Maya: So rents have basically gone flat.

Ben: Flat in nominal terms, which after inflation means renters are slowly getting some relief. That's one of the quieter good-news stories in housing right now.

Maya: And prices over the full ten years?

Ben: A typical Phoenix home went from $218,000 to $455,000. Tampa, from $214,000 to $479,000. Nashville, from $250,000 to $476,000. Danville went from $1.11M to $1.82M.

Maya: Some of those roughly doubled.

Ben: Phoenix, Tampa and Indianapolis more or less did. But here's something that surprises people. Several of the boom markets are still below their peaks. Danville's median topped out at $2.15M in July 2022. Fort Worth peaked at $365,000 in July 2022, and South Lake Tahoe at $730,000 in June 2022. Meanwhile Indianapolis set its high in August 2026. The places that ran hottest are giving a little back; the steady Midwest is still grinding higher.

Maya: That's a pattern I wouldn't have guessed.

Ben: It's the tortoise and the hare, with mortgages.

Maya: Let's go on the ground. If you had to describe what's happening across the country this week, using our markets as examples, what's the story?

Ben: I'd call it the great slow-down, not the great crash. Prices mostly aren't falling. Behavior is changing instead. Take Nashville. There are 5,321 homes for sale, 5.8 months of supply, and homes take 64 days to sell. That's a market where buyers have time again.

Maya: Time is leverage.

Ben: Time is the main form of leverage a buyer ever has. Then look at Dallas. Pending sales, contracts signed, are down 8.8% from a year ago. Contracts lead closings by a month or two, so that's a look ahead, and the look ahead is quieter.

Maya: Where are sellers giving ground?

Ben: Price cuts tell you. In Indianapolis, 43.8% of listings have had at least one cut. Fort Worth, 41.4%. Tampa, 42.0%. That's sellers discovering, one listing at a time, that last year's price is this year's opening bid.

Maya: And yet Tampa prices are up.

Ben: Tampa's median is up 10.0% from a year ago, even though homes take 21.1% longer to sell than last year. That's what I'd call a disagreement between the official statement and the body language. Prices are sticky. Behavior moves first.

Maya: Is anything getting tighter?

Ben: Danville. Only 93 homes for sale, but pending sales are up 7.3%, the strongest of any market we track. In the most expensive place we cover, demand is holding up best. That's the wealth effect: the buyers there aren't living on local paychecks alone. And Ann Arbor is interesting in the other direction. Listings there are up 29.2% from a year ago, but it's a small, university-driven market, so even a big percentage move is a modest number of homes.

Maya: You keep saying prices aren't falling. But are they really not?

Ben: Not on the sticker, mostly. But adjust for inflation and they are. After inflation, the typical home in Nashville is down 3.7% from a year ago. Fort Worth, down 5.2%. Oklahoma City, down 3.7%. Dallas, down 3.3%. This is how housing usually corrects. Not with a crash, but with a long stall, while inflation quietly does the work.

Maya: The money illusion.

Ben: Exactly. People remember the price they paid, not what a dollar was worth when they paid it. So a correction in real terms barely registers emotionally. Nobody gets a letter saying their house is worth less in real dollars.

Maya: Here's what I hear most from people: why is nobody selling? Every neighborhood seems to have fewer For Sale signs than it used to.

Ben: That's the lock-in effect, and it's the single most important national force in housing right now. Most American homeowners with a mortgage have a fixed rate, and a huge number of them locked in during those years when rates were in the low single digits. Today's rate is 7.03%. Selling means trading a cheap loan for an expensive one, so people stay put unless life forces a move: a new job, a growing family, a divorce, a retirement.

Maya: So supply is low not because people don't want to move, but because moving got expensive.

Ben: Right. And builders can't fully fill the gap. Housing starts nationally are running at an annual pace of about 1.27 million, down from 1.81 million at the high in May 2022.

Maya: Which brings us to something I wanted to ask. Is the American system unusual? Because the lock-in effect sounds very American.

Ben: It is very American, and this is one of my favorite topics. The 30-year fixed-rate mortgage that you can refinance any time without penalty is rare in the rest of the world.

Maya: What do other countries do?

Ben: In Canada, most borrowers lock their rate for a few years at a time and then renew at whatever rates are by then. In Britain, people typically fix for two to five years and then refinance or roll onto a variable rate. In Australia, most mortgages float with the central bank's rate. So when rates jumped worldwide, households in those countries felt it in their monthly payments within months or a couple of years.

Maya: And Americans didn't.

Ben: Americans with fixed loans didn't feel it at all. Their payment stayed exactly the same. That's a gift to existing owners. But the bill came due somewhere else: in frozen supply, because nobody wanted to give up their loan. In Canada or Australia, the rate shock hit owners. In the United States, it hit movers and first-time buyers.

Maya: That's a really different way to share the pain.

Ben: It's a choice societies make without realizing it. Denmark has a fascinating version. Danes can get long fixed-rate mortgages funded by bonds, and when rates rise, the bonds behind their mortgage fall in price, so a borrower can buy back their own debt at a discount. It's like your mortgage shrinking when rates go up. That makes it much easier to move.

Maya: That's genuinely clever.

Ben: It's one of those designs economists love and almost nobody outside Denmark has heard of.

Maya: What about ownership itself? Is owning a home as central everywhere as it is here?

Ben: Not at all. In the United States, roughly two-thirds of households own. In Germany, about half of households rent, and in Switzerland most households rent. Renting there is a normal, long-term choice for middle-class families, backed by strong tenant protections. Nobody thinks of a forty-year-old renter in Munich or Zurich as having failed at something.

Maya: That's a cultural difference as much as an economic one.

Ben: Very much. In the American story, owning is how families build wealth, partly because the tax code and the 30-year mortgage made it the easiest form of forced saving. In Germany, people save in other ways, and housing is more purely about shelter.

Maya: Where does housing work completely differently?

Ben: Japan is the one that breaks people's mental models. A typical Japanese house loses most of its value within a few decades. Buyers are really paying for the land, and houses are often torn down and rebuilt. Homes are treated more like cars than like investments.

Maya: That would never fly here.

Ben: It would change everything about how Americans think of a house. And there's a second Japan lesson. Tokyo's zoning rules are set nationally and are relatively permissive, so when the city grew, it kept building. Rents there have stayed remarkably steady for a big, desirable city. It's the most cited example of a place that let supply follow demand.

Maya: Any others?

Ben: Singapore, where around four in five residents live in public housing flats, most of them owned on leases that run for most of a century. Vienna, where a large share of residents live in city-owned or subsidized housing, and it's mixed-income, not a last resort. And then there's the other end: Toronto, Vancouver and Sydney have price-to-income levels well above most American cities. Canada and New Zealand have both restricted foreign buyers, partly in response to that.

Maya: And China?

Ben: China is the cautionary tale about housing as a savings account. Property became a huge share of household wealth, and when the big developers got into debt trouble, the slump weighed on household confidence across the whole economy. When housing is where a country keeps its savings, a housing downturn becomes everyone's downturn.

Maya: So where does the US land, if you step back?

Ben: American housing is unusually good at protecting existing owners and unusually bad at adding supply in the places people most want to live. The mortgage system is a fortress. The zoning system is a moat. Put those together and you get exactly what we see in our data: stable owners, frozen inventory, and buyers who have to wait for rates or for life to shake loose a few listings.

Maya: Okay. Before the billion dollars, I want to do a couple of economist curiosities. You told me there's something strange about how housing shows up in inflation.

Ben: There is. Shelter is the biggest single piece of the consumer price index, about a third of it. But for homeowners, the government doesn't measure home prices. It estimates what owners would pay if they rented their own homes to themselves. It's called owners' equivalent rent.

Maya: Renting your house to yourself.

Ben: Imaginary rent, measured with real surveys. It's a defensible choice, because a house is partly an investment and the price index is supposed to measure consumption. But it means that the boom in home prices showed up in inflation slowly, through rents, and the cooling in rents we just talked about shows up slowly too. It's one reason inflation can stay sticky after the housing market has already turned.

Maya: Second curiosity. You keep saying prices are sticky. Why? Everything else gets repriced constantly.

Ben: Because a house is the only thing most people sell maybe two or three times in their life, and they remember exactly what they paid. Psychologists call it loss aversion and anchoring. A seller would rather wait six months than accept a price below what they paid or below what the neighbor got. So in a downturn, the first thing that moves isn't price. It's volume. Sales dry up, listings sit, and only later do prices give.

Maya: Which is what we're seeing.

Ben: It's exactly what we're seeing. Days on market up, price cuts up, sticker prices flat, real prices falling.

Maya: Last curiosity: is a house a good investment or not? I feel like people argue about this forever.

Ben: They argue because a house is two products bundled together. One is shelter, which you'd be paying for anyway. The other is a leveraged bet on land in one specific place. When people say a house was a great investment, they're usually crediting the bet for returns that partly came from not paying rent. And when people say it's a bad investment, they're forgetting that rent isn't free. The honest answer is that it depends on the price of the shelter part versus the bet part, and that's what ratios like price-to-rent try to capture.

Maya: Okay. The billion dollars. Here's the thought experiment. You have a billion dollars to put to work in American housing. Not advice, nobody listening has a billion dollars, probably, but how would an economist actually think about it?

Ben: First the disclaimer: this is a thought experiment about how different kinds of investors reason, not a recommendation for anyone. Real decisions depend on taxes, timelines and everything else someone owns.

Maya: Understood. So where do you start?

Ben: Not with markets. With the job you want the money to do. A billion dollars could be asked to produce income, or growth, or resilience, or impact. Each of those draws a completely different map of the same country.

Maya: Start with income.

Ben: Income is the simplest. You'd look at gross rental yield, a year of rent as a share of the price. Indianapolis is at 6.4%. Fort Worth, 5.8%. Oklahoma City, 5.6%. Danville, 2.7%. The typical market we track is at 4.8%.

Maya: And cash?

Ben: Cash-like savings track the Fed's rate, which is 3.88%. So in Danville, rent pays less than parked cash, before you've paid a single expense. An income-first investor would find almost nothing to like there and a lot more to like in the middle of the country.

Maya: But Danville prices keep going up.

Ben: Which is the growth job. Buying in Danville is a bet on appreciation and scarcity, not income. There are only 93 homes for sale and demand is the strongest we track. A growth-first investor accepts thin income in exchange for owning something scarce. The risk is that scarcity is already in the price.

Maya: Here's the part I find most interesting, though. You said something earlier about lending versus owning.

Ben: This is the economist's favorite observation right now. The 30-year mortgage rate is 7.03%. The highest gross rental yield in any market we track is Indianapolis, at 6.4%. So in every single one of our markets, the rate a lender earns on a home loan is higher than the rent an owner collects, before the owner's costs.

Maya: So right now the economy pays you more to lend against houses than to own them.

Ben: On paper, yes. A lender takes credit risk and gives up the upside if prices rise, so it's not a free lunch. But it tells you something about where the market is. When the cost of money is above the income a house produces, the only reason to own for investment is the expectation of appreciation. A billion-dollar allocator would notice that and ask whether some of the money belongs on the lending side of the table.

Maya: What about the resilience job?

Ben: Resilience means: what holds up if things go wrong? There I'd look at affordability. In Indianapolis, a typical payment takes 25.1% of the median income. Oklahoma City, 25.6%. Compare that with Danville at 50.1%. Affordable markets don't need perfect conditions to keep working. When rates jump or a recession hits, they have room to bend.

Maya: And impact?

Ben: Impact is where it gets philosophical. The biggest problem in American housing isn't who owns the existing homes. It's that there aren't enough of them where people want to live. Buying existing houses just changes who the owner is. Financing new construction adds homes. In a place like Danville, with 2.0 months of supply, or South Lake Tahoe, with 164 homes for sale, the most useful thing money can do may be building, not bidding.

Maya: But building is hard there.

Ben: Building is hard almost everywhere scarcity is worst. That's not a coincidence. It's the reason the scarcity exists.

Maya: And then there's patience.

Ben: Patience is underrated. In markets where buyers have leverage, like Nashville with 5.8 months of supply, or Dallas with contracts down 8.8%, someone with cash can negotiate on price, repairs and timing. That's leverage, not a forecast. And money waiting on the sidelines isn't idle. At 3.88%, cash pays something while you wait.

Maya: So if I made you sketch the billion dollars, what would the sketch look like?

Ben: I'd sketch it as a portfolio of jobs rather than a list of cities. Some money doing the income job where rents carry the price. Some doing the building job where supply is scarcest. Some on the lending side while rates are high. Some waiting, earning cash rates, for the markets where buyers are gaining leverage. And spread across regions, because the risks are different everywhere: insurance and storms in Florida, heat and water in the Southwest, energy in Oklahoma, a single university in a college town.

Maya: Diversification, but by purpose.

Ben: Exactly. Which markets fill each job changes as the numbers change, and that's what a weekly score is for. It's a map of conditions, not a buy list. And for anyone listening with an actual decision in front of them: a household isn't a fund. A house you live in is mostly about whether you can comfortably carry it through a bad stretch, and that's a conversation for you and a professional who knows your situation.

Maya: Let's close with what to watch over the next year, nationally.

Ben: Five things. First, mortgage rates. A year ago the 30-year rate was 6.30%. If rates drifted back toward that, the lock-in effect would start to ease, and more owners would finally list. Second, contracts. Pending sales are the earliest signal, and if they stop falling in markets like Dallas, the slowdown is stabilizing.

Maya: Third?

Ben: Price cuts and days on market. If the share of listings with cuts levels off, sellers have found the market. If it keeps climbing, the next thing to give is the sticker price. Fourth, rents versus prices. When rents grow faster than prices, rental yields fatten and the income case for owning gets stronger. Right now rents are roughly flat, so that's a slow story.

Maya: And fifth?

Ben: The costs our numbers don't capture. Insurance, property taxes and maintenance have become a much bigger part of owning in some places. A payment-to-income figure that looks fine can hide an insurance bill that doesn't.

Maya: Any closing thought? You always have one.

Ben: Here's mine. Ten years of data taught me that conditions change much faster than prices do. In three years, every market we track went from its best reading to its worst. Prices barely flinched. If you want to understand housing, watch the conditions, because the prices are always the last to know.

Maya: That's HousingGauge National. Every market's weekly score and its own podcast are at housinggauge.com.

Ben: And the usual fine print: the HousingGauge score describes market conditions. It isn't a recommendation to buy or sell, and it isn't individualized financial advice.

Maya: Thanks for spending some real time with us. See you next time.

AI-voiced conversation. Every figure comes from HousingGauge data; international comparisons are general background, not HousingGauge statistics. Not a recommendation or individualized financial advice.